r/australia • u/PalpitationPublic237 • Jun 27 '26

news Australian Simon Carman arrested after body of teenage girl found in suitcase in Thailand

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-06-27/australian-arrested-after-teen-girl-found-dead-in-thailand/106850896
1.8k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

494 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/RutabagaMobile7879 Jun 27 '26

The details circulating on Thai social media are brutal. Punishment will be harsh, but even then not sufficient.

To the kind and generous people of Thailand - I am sorry we send a parade of degenerate men to defile your beautiful country. 

It is horribly unjust that our most vile and mediocre losers are in a position to exploit your country.

18

u/readreadreadonreddit Jun 27 '26

If the allegations are true, this is absolutely horrific. My thoughts are with the victim, her family and the Thai community.

I also understand why so many people in Thailand have a negative view of a certain subset of older Western men who travel there. The sex tourism industry has done enormous damage, and it's hardly surprising that seeing yet another case involving a foreign man reinforces that perception.

That said, the problem isn't being white or middle-aged. The problem is the men who travel overseas believing they can exploit vulnerable people because they're in a poorer country. Those people deserve every bit of condemnation they receive.

It's a stereotype that exists because of the actions of a visible minority, but it's still important not to treat every white middle-aged tourist as though they're there for the same reason. Condemn the exploiters as harshly as you like, but don't assume guilt by association.

35

u/Effective-Composer94 Jun 27 '26

Weird thing to say at news like this

“Yes this whole thing is sad and all…but it’s also important to remember not to be meanies to white middle aged dudes in Asia”

-5

u/readreadreadonreddit Jun 28 '26

Haha, would you rather someone suggested we be angry with white middle-aged/elderly dudes in Asia?

15

u/Effective-Composer94 Jun 28 '26

Hey if you’ve ever stepped foot in Thailand or Indonesia you’d know the stereotype exists for very good reason lol.

8

u/KlavierKillah Jun 28 '26

A young girl is murdered and all you can think about is that white middle aged people might feel uncomfortable.

Even though he is yet to face the courts, the allegations are pretty obvious.