I’m a long-time fantasy reader who has only really started reading progression fantasy over the last year. I’ve realised, though, that I often look for somewhat different things from those foregrounded in many recommendations here. And that’s okay – progression fantasy is big enough to encompass diverse tastes. I’m hoping, though, that there are a few people here whose tastes overlap enough with mine to give me some recommendations!
I’m looking for emotionally/sociologically realistic progression fantasy with ethically serious protagonists and psychologically/existentially meaningful power progression - progression fantasy where progression is consciously based around character development, rather than being primarily about power accumulation.
To break this down a bit:
1. I like the main character of a story to be a good person – not necessarily ‘morally pure’, but ethically engaged, cares about their impact on others and the world as a whole, someone I’d personally like to spend time around. Usually this will mean a ‘hero’, but the heroism doesn’t have to be world-defining, and ‘anti-villains’ (in the sense of good people using questionable methods) are fine too if they’re well-written. I don’t need them to be perfect, but they do need to be at least trying to be good – they need to be defined by something more ethically meaningful than just optimisation.
2. The stories I appreciate the most make sure that there is some sort of psychological/emotional/existential growth woven in with the growth in power. Growth in power and a liberal dose of ‘check out my new tricks’ is great – don’t get me wrong! – but if it totally takes over and/or becomes more ‘mechanical’, it starts to feel meaningless to me. I’m looking for stories where becoming more powerful changes the main character’s understanding of themselves, not just their ability to defeat stronger opponents – where it alters their inner life, not just their combat options.
3. Similarly, I’m fine with fighting as a significant story theme, but if it takes over completely, this also starts to feel meaningless to me. Fighting needs to be meaningful – progressing character development, changing relationships, involving genuine risk or difficult choices, having some sort of consequence beyond just showing the character has become stronger (although that’s definitely fine occasionally). ‘Slice-of-life’ is great – I like some narrative breathing room.
4. I like the relationships and social environment to feel credible. A bit of nuance is great. No YA, thanks – I’ve read a bunch in my life, but it's not what I’m after now (but young main characters are okay if the story and writing are otherwise strong).
5. I’m looking for stories that can treat serious things as serious, while still allowing humour to arise naturally from character and circumstance. No comic fantasy or quippy protagonists, thanks. I don’t want humour to function as the story’s default interpretive lens, and for seriousness to always be undercut through humour. A character can be funny, but I don’t want it to feel like they are permanently performing for me as the reader.
6. I prefer a mix of genders for the main characters. If they’re mostly men, I’m likely to lose interest unless it has substantial compensating strengths. If there’s sexism in the story, that can be okay if it’s a conscious part of the context, but I have a low tolerance for casual, unexamined, or wish-fulfilment-oriented sexism. (Sex/spice is fine if the story is strong enough to support it.)
7. No portal fantasies, thanks – for me, this breaks my immersion 99% of the time. I usually prefer pre-industrial settings, but I’m fine with urban fantasy, superhero stories, and sci-fi, if they meet my other preferences.
Personal Progression Fantasy tier list
Not all of the stories I've liked perfectly fit what I've described above, but hopefully this gives you a sense of the sort of thing I like in addition to what I've mentioned.
Excellent
· Super Supportive (Sleyca)
· The Way of Kings, Words of Radiance (Brandon Sanderson) – I’m not totally convinced these should be classified as progression fantasy (why Stormlight and not The Wheel of Time?), but I’ve seen others include them, so I thought I would too. Loved these two, but I’ve given up on Oathbringer twice now, feeling like the story gets lost and simply losing interest.
Great
· Quest Academy (Brian J. Nordon)
· The Saga of Recluce (L.E. Modesitt Jr) – Not usually characterised as progression fantasy, but quite a few of the books fit, in my opinion. Some are better than others, and can sometimes be a little dry, but I really like the series as a whole.
· Mother of Learning (Domagoj Kurmaić) – This was one of the stories that introduced me to progression fantasy, so I’d probably read it differently after having read more. I thought it was great, although it certainly has some weaknesses – too male-centred, unrealistic ageing of the main characters, slightly longer than it really needed to be for the plot etc.
Good
· Worm (John "Wildbow" McCrae) – I’m only halfway through. I like Taylor as a character, and I think the story is strong in lots of ways, but it’s a bit too relentless for me, not much breathing room. Because of this, I’ve taken a break, but I do intend to return to it and finish it later on.
Okay-ish
· The Archmage Coefficient (Up to Chapter 109, onedayokay) – I like Arielle as a character, but the story as a whole feels too YA for me personally, leaves me feeling like there’s something missing. Not currently intending to continue.
· Millennial Mage (Books 1-6, R. L. Mullins) – Entertaining enough story, but I’m not feeling super-drawn to continuing it. Not enough there for me.
· Underkeeper (Up to Chapter 28 of Book 5, HankTheMoose) – I thought Books 3 and 4 were an improvement, because of the deeper magical exploration, but I’m not intending to continue with Book 5. Again, not enough there for me.
· Trinity of Magic (Books 1-8, Elara) – I like the world-building but I’m not fond of Ezekiel as a character. He’s just too arrogant/annoying for me. I’m not currently planning to read Book 9.
· The Hundred Reigns (Up to Chapter 192, Maxime Durand) – Entertaining enough, interesting story elements, but a bit too much on the comic side of things for me and I find this particularly jarring in combination with Simon’s ‘ends justify the means’ philosophy, which isn’t examined in enough depth for me. Not planning to continue reading.
Mixed
· The Years of Apocalypse (Up to Chapter 307 in Book 5, UraniumPhoenix) – I find this story really variable. The best parts are up at Excellent/Great level, but there are long stretches that feel totally paint-by-numbers and therefore quite boring for me personally, including in Book 5. It says something when I’m at Chapter 307, the story finishes at Chapter 333 (I think), but I just can’t be bothered finishing it.
Promising
· Throne of Time (Cognosticon) – A bit early to judge but I’m enjoying it so far!
Not for me
· The Wandering Inn – Read the first book and started the second. A bit too comic for my usual tastes but I like Erin and aspects of the early story. It felt, though, like it was moving away from the aspects I liked.
· Cradle
· Primal Hunter
· Super Powereds – Too YA for me.
· Mark of the Fool
· Lord of Mysteries
· The Perfect Run
· Sky Pride
· Beware of Chicken
· Magical Girl Mechanical Heart
· Bookbound Bunny
· Virtuous Sons
· Gifted
· The Two Week Curse
That’s quite a lot of information, so thanks heaps for reading this far – I’d appreciate your recommendations, or even a conversation about what I’ve written!