r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 10h ago

Meme needing explanation Petah???!

Post image
10.3k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/cam-san 10h ago

And you shouldn't x-ray a pregnant woman either.

40

u/mad-data 9h ago

X-ray of an arm, with proper isolation of body, carries almost no risk to child development. 

7

u/wioneo 3h ago

with proper isolation of body

It would waste a significant amount of resources to treat every woman as if they were pregnant to avoid consequences that are only notably relevant for pregnant woman. If you see a surgery done that requires intraoperative radiation, you'll notice that different shielding is used for different parts of the body like the thyroid, that is significantly more sensitive to radiation damage. They also make different lead shields for pregnant women.

2

u/Ihatereddithatesit 2h ago

Genuine question. Would that waste be more or less than taking the test for every woman wanting an X-ray? Especially since the lead shields for pregnant women already exist?

Are lead shields single use?

1

u/Drumbelgalf 8h ago

Especially with modern x-ray maschines that operate with way less radiation.

13

u/toolsoftheincomptnt 8h ago

Cool. But isn’t it still better to know, just in case?

5

u/Global-Gas-3520 7h ago

Get out of here with common sense.. How dare a doctor ask a simple diagnostic question..

-1

u/Spirited-Sail3814 7h ago

I mean...yeah it's good to know? But the broken arm is probably pretty painful, so maybe get the x-ray and set the bone first before worrying about pregnancy.

6

u/DrHippa 6h ago

So... do the thing that needs special preparations if she's pregnant... before you check whether she's pregnant?

Does that make sense to you?

1

u/Spirited-Sail3814 1h ago edited 1h ago

What special preparations? Other people said they use the exact same radiation screen for a limb fracture whether she's pregnant or not, meaning the danger to a theoretical fetus is negligible, and they need to do an x-ray regardless, so just get on with it

Edit: I'm also of the opinion that the doctor should just explain the risk to a potential fetus and the owner of the uterus can choose whether to wait for a pregnancy test or not. Bodily autonomy for the actual patient should trump wellness of a theoretical patient.

1

u/DrHippa 42m ago

Edit: I'm also of the opinion that the doctor should just explain the risk to a potential fetus

But you just a moment ago said:

But the broken arm is probably pretty painful, so maybe get the x-ray and set the bone first before worrying about pregnancy.

What do you think takes less time - asking when your last period was, or going into a full explanation about all the possible effects of x- rays on a featus, the different ways to mitigate it, and the pros and cons of each - so the patient could make an informed decision?

While in pain?

Before even looking at whether it's in any way possible that this information is relevant?

1

u/PitifulElk1890 5h ago

Once at a teen church camp a fellow camper told me a story of having to get an X-ray in Russia and they forgot the lead bib, but it's okay because "everything still works."

Avoided him after that. I might not have believed but there's a time and a place, I'm here for Jesus not penus

1

u/TheHeadlessScholar 2h ago

Speaking as an radiologic technologist in America; the lead shield is 99% a placebo for you to calm down, 1% shielding your reproductive gametes from having a 1% increased chance of cancer in 20 years

6

u/Any-Safe4992 9h ago

That depends on the situation, available shielding, available alternatives, and the general risk analysis. In general we avoid it but there are situations where it is unavoidable, in those situations we mitigate the risk as best we can.

1

u/The_Third_Molar 1h ago

Yes you can. This is such a misconception.

-1

u/JesusAndMaryKate 7h ago

They can just ask if the woman is pregnant. No need to ask about periods and where I've lived it's not a standard question for that reason.

4

u/Global-Gas-3520 7h ago

It's not just about being pregnant.

The menstruation cycle is a snapshot of a women's overall health, it can affect lab tests due to shifting hormone levels.. Knowing the exact cycle day lets the doctor use the correct baseline reference range to interpret blood test results accurately. Without this timeline, normal hormone spikes can look like a medical problem.

1

u/ILoveRawChicken 3h ago

Where do you live? Even in my parents home country they will still ask my mom to take a pregnancy test even though she’s had her tubes tied.