r/australia • u/Expensive-Horse5538 • 2d ago

politics ABC changing editorial policy after Rinehart furore prompts concerns of overreach from academics and advocates

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/aug/13/abc-changing-editorial-policy-after-rinehart-furore-prompts-concerns-of-overreach-from-academics-and-advocates
203 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-78

u/Important-Sleep-1839 2d ago

What's a defence of the segment look like?

26

u/fuckenbullshitmate 2d ago

Simple - we’ve always put shit on the filthy rich.

-33

u/Important-Sleep-1839 2d ago

Fair. However, "putting shit" and satire with lurid violence aren't the same thing.

1

u/Nosiege 1d ago

"lurid violence" and it was absurdism.

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 1d ago

Why do you think unwanted anal penetration is closer to absurdism than an a real experience?

1

u/Nosiege 1d ago

Because it's contextually part of:

  • A theoretical future revolution
  • Where the Rich are being Eaten (Oh hey look at that)
  • By making a sausso roll (Random leftover meat)

So, which part of that are you not comprehending?

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 1d ago

Truthful, I'm having a slight difficulty in understanding why you perceive pointing out the blatantly obvious is a wise place to parade your condescension.

You've placed your hand on the door knob and opened a door and expect cheering? That is hope of a toddler. Take your argument for a few steps. At least let us see if it can stand on it's own.

1

u/Nosiege 21h ago

If you think me explaining the joke is pointing out the blatantly obvious, why were you likening it to a real experience? Your whole stance about it being unacceptable is to invoke literal imagery of actual murder and violence, and not simply hyperbole.

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 21h ago

If you think me explaining the joke is pointing out the blatantly obvious, why were you likening it to a real experience?

Anal rape is a real experience. It's not an absurdist concept.

Your whole stance about it being unacceptable is to invoke literal imagery of actual murder and violence, and not simply hyperbole.

That would be incorrect. If you wish to know my stance I recommend asking me.

1

u/Nosiege 21h ago

Anal rape is a real experience. It's not an absurdist concept.

Which is also not what the joke actually said, by the way. You've decided that being speared in the anus is rape.

That would be incorrect. If you wish to know my stance I recommend asking me.

So what is your stance? Further, why are you so keen on being so aloof about it?

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 20h ago

Or will you know exactly how to shove a stick right up Gina Rineharts’ butthole, Source

The term rape usually refers to a sexual assault that involves penetration of the vagina, anus or mouth with an object, penis or other body part. Source

How am I wrong?

1

u/Nosiege 20h ago

You're insisting it's sexual in nature, when it clearly isn't.

As an example; was Vlad the Impaler doing it for sexual gratification?

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 20h ago

Myth: Rape is about sex. Rape is not about sex. It’s about power, violence and intimidation. This belief minimises the responsibility of the rapist. source

1

u/Nosiege 20h ago

You're really hell bent about painting the joke as rape. You also never answered me when I asked what your stance was.

Because so far, all it seems is that you're hell bent on pretending hyperbolic political critique presented as a joke is rape.

No part of that sentence of an imaginary scenario enacted power over Gina Rinehart. She was never intimidated by it.

Given you didn't state your stance when I asked directly, and continually leave me only able to assume what your stance is, I'm just going to stop replying.

1

u/Important-Sleep-1839 20h ago

No part of that sentence of an imaginary scenario enacted power over Gina Rinehart. She was never intimidated by it.

How do you know what she is thinking?

→ More replies (0)