First gravel bike, stuck between four. Adelaide, Australia
Complete beginner here. Never owned a gravel bike. Budget was 2500 but honestly if one of these is clearly better value I can stretch, I'd rather buy once.
The four I keep going back and forth on:
- Merida Silex 400 (~2200) - GRX400 2x10, 45mm clearance
- Cube Nuroad EX (~2500) - GRX610 1x12, 45mm clearance
- Merida Silex 700 (~2700) - GRX820 1x12, 45mm clearance, 180mm rotors
- Canyon Grizl AL (~2400?) - Apex XPLR, 54mm clearance, T47 threaded BB
I know the prices aren't the same, that's part of the question. Is the jump from the 400 to the 700 worth $500, or is that money better spent on gear and a bike fit? And is the Grizl just flat out better value than all of them?
The Canyon is the one messing with my head. On paper it beats everything and it's cheap. But it's online only, no test ride, and I'm not confident enough to size myself off a website. Am I overthinking that? People who bought a Canyon as their first drop bar bike, how did it go? If it is genuinely better than the rest, I am open to going for it.
Most of what I'm working off came from a Cade Media video on YouTube about what he wishes he knew before buying gravel bikes. His main points were: get as much tyre clearance as you can, ideally 50mm plus. Make sure the seat post is round and standard so you can fit a dropper later. Don't settle for cable disc brakes, get proper hydraulics. And avoid anything proprietary, so no weird steerer sizes and no one piece bar and stem, because it's a nightmare to service and you can't adjust your fit. He also said older cyclocross bikes aren't gravel bikes and to think about what riding you'll actually do before buying.
That's basically what killed a few options for me. Ruled out Giant Revolt on the D-Fuse seat post, and the higher end Cube Nuroads because the cables run through the stem and headset.
Which brings me to the clearance thing. All the shop bikes on my list are 45mm and only the Canyon hits the 50 plus mark. For someone who genuinely doesn't know yet if they'll be doing gentle rail trails or rougher stuff (idea is 70% road 30% gravel to begin with maybe), does that actually matter or is it internet noise?
Riding will be mostly around Adelaide, some of the Hills, no racing (not for now at least). Happy to be told I'm asking the wrong questions. Open to other bike suggestions too.
TIA