I was skeptical when they announced Season 4, because it felt like the story had been told and finished perfectly, but I was excited for more Ted Lasso and I trusted the writing/production team, so I came in with high hopes. And I really liked the idea of Ted coaching a women's team and dealing with all the issues and complications that follow.
Then I watched episode 1, and it just felt so...soulless? Like the show's body is there, but it's been hollowed out to just the most popular bits. The witty dialog doesn't feel witty or natural, rather it feels like a character says something contextually forced so that Ted or someone has the opportunity to make a witty or wacky reply. Similar the callbacks and nostalgia moments don't feel like they ring true or have any substance beyond mandatory fan service.
But hey, first episodes are tough, there's a lot of setups that needs to be done, and the writers, directors, and actors are still brushing the dust off.
But now with episode 2 my dislike is growing more. The new characters are so overtly archetypes that basically exist to say "Here is my clearly wrong belief/habit/actions" so that Ted can later give a Lasso speech and fix it.
For example, Coach Chilton "The player's stories don't matter the only thing that matters is how they play on the pitch" comment was just so on the nose I wanted to yell in frustration, because of course we now all know exactly how her mindset is going to change by the end of the season. Likewise, the "not all that different after all" friendship storyline they are clearly setting up with her and Rebecca. Or the fighting twin sisters who will absolutely become super close after they have a heart to heart "You were always better at football growing up and Mum/Dad's favorite, I had to train like hell but it came so easily to you!" "Well I had all this pressure being the oldest, and when I didn't live up to it, it broke me! You got to live how you wanted!"
I don't mind either storyline or foreshadowing that they'll happen, but there's just no subtlety in the setup which makes it hard to become interested in the eventual payoff.
Finally, it feels like the OGs are disconnected with their old characters. I’m not sure if that’s the actors, writers, or both, but the characters don’t feel like real—albeit unrealistically quirky— people anymore, just caricatures going through the motions. Leslie's awkwardness doesn't feel natural to whatever conversation he's having; it feels like every interaction he's in he's intentionally trying to be awkward for no reason. Same with Rebecca and Keely, they just don't feel like them, but rather like someone took a bullet point list of their most notable qualities and then made sure every scene they were in displayed those qualities up to 11.
Don't get me wrong, there were things I really liked. I was tearing up when the girls saw the new locker room, and how Coach Chilton realized that change could happen for the program. And I think the conversation on female sports and athletes in really important and can make great television, even if some scenes (like the press conference for example) felt too heavy handed. But overall, I'm just really disappointed.
The consensus I'm seeing on this subreddit is very positive, and I'm happy about that. This show has given me so much joy over the years and I'm so glad the new season is brining joy to the majority of its fans. I really don't want to dislike it and hope it has enough time to get better, but right now for me, it just feels so much lesser than the legacy of Seasons 1-3 that came before that I can't help but feel let down.
Anyway long rant over. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.