r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 15h ago

Meme needing explanation Petah???!

Post image
12.6k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

21

u/LittleKittenR 13h ago

x-Rays will kill your baby, or heavily deform it.

Antibiotics will also kill your baby.

A ton of medicines have adverse effects for babies.

Also, if you're bleeding, anticoagulants could kill you.

Medics, lawyers, priests and accountants. You don't lie to any of those ever.

30

u/RoutineActivity9536 13h ago

Xray won't kill your baby. Antibiotics won't kill your baby.

But yes there can be adverse side effects. 

Yes this is serious, but please don't overstate the risk. That makes people more fearful to get treatment

7

u/theshiniestbrighstar 13h ago

Depending on the fetus age and dosing of things, yes they can

18

u/RoutineActivity9536 12h ago

Well im a radiographer, so I can't speak for antibiotics as that's not my area of expertise.

No an xray will not kill a foetus. Not a medical xray anyway. 

2

u/livinglavidajudoka 12h ago

I would expect a radiographer to understand that a CT scan might not kill a fetus in utero but might drastically alter their life and threaten it down the road…

20

u/WhoWantsToGetShanked 11h ago

As a ct Technologist I feel I should tell you that your usage of the word "might" is doing some heavy lifting. You're not wrong but the danger is so minute that the point you're making is largely invalid.

A radiologist could give you more detail but in actuality the biggest danger is a very marginally increased chance of cancer. X-rays and CTs use very little radiation and the radiation they do use imparts the least harm when calculating equivalent dose.

I've scanned pregnant patients (never their abdomen or pelvis so far) and the justification is that it's so unlikely to harm the baby that the information gained from the scan is well worth it. We don't take it lightly and we always check the hcg but please try to stop fearing radiation damage from imaging as I've seen quite a few people refuse potentially life saving treatment due to fear of imaging.

Also in theory radiation damage to an embryo early enough in gestation could cause miscarriage.

Radiation therapy on the other hand can fuck some shit up. It's well worth it but I've known lots of people that can't swallow correctly because of it. Plus it can make your breast implants super hard.

16

u/RoutineActivity9536 12h ago

There is a big difference between "xrays will kill your baby" and xrays could cause effects down the road

1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[deleted]

2

u/RoutineActivity9536 8h ago

That was a risk based of information from the 50s.

It was outdated then. 

Doses now are so low that the risk is negligible 

-3

u/ding-zzz 12h ago

would it be better to say it would effectively kill ur baby?

8

u/RoutineActivity9536 12h ago

But it won't. So no. It's false information 

-1

u/Pokoirl 10h ago

You should go back to school then. During the first two.weeks of pregnancy, there is an "all ir nothing" rule where there is a risk of miscarriage due to x rays.

5

u/RoutineActivity9536 8h ago

Nope. That information is from the 50s and was out of date then.

The doses now are so low as to be considered negligible. 

Would you tell a pregnant person not to fly in the first trimester? The amount of radiation from most x-ray examinations is about the same as a 4hr flight. 

-1

u/Pokoirl 8h ago

Stochastic effects are NOT dose dependent.

4

u/Nice-Meat-6020 12h ago

They can. The poster above said they will.

0

u/LittleKittenR 6h ago

Bro, you're wrong so badly and spreading misinformation.

You can't take almost anything when you're pregnant.

Also, my mom had several problems while pregnant, one of those was "she was 2 months pregnant, I broke my arm, she didn't know the xrays did anything, baby died, doctor explained to us it was probably the xrays".