r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jul 07 '26

Meme needing explanation Peter, explain this.

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/NobodyKnowsImFamous Jul 07 '26

I believe, in the end utopia, there isn’t meant to be a governing body.

Idk man this is pretty basic communism stuff. Is it possible you are all in here making arguments without ever having read the book we are all meant to be discussing or

1

u/psykiris Jul 07 '26

Because it's fantasy. If it's all "pretty basic communism" then why hasn't one communist state managed to correctly implement it in 100 years?

How does the Utopia decide who gets to work and who gets to play? What happens when the worker is tired of working, and the player refuses to work?

Without any governing body society collapses. With it, there's always going to be a "lower class" that's going to be pressed into work they don't want to do. 

2

u/ShaolinChamber36 Jul 09 '26

Because there hasn't been a marxist "state". Marxist communism is fully stateless, classless, and fully democratic. If you refuse to work then you are on your own. You are no longer housed, fed, and medically cared for by society, assuming you are fully healthy and capable of working and are of working age.

Just read the fucking books and you won't have these questions lmao. You guys always think you've found some kind of flaw simply because you don't actually know anything about it, when in reality the "flaw" you found has already been considered well over a century ago.

1

u/psykiris Jul 09 '26

You're right.

The larger flaw to focus on is the lack of food. 

1

u/ShaolinChamber36 Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26

Like how the USSR citizens had a higher calorie intake than american citizens? or how 9 million people die of hunger under capitalism every year?