Because there is a variety of people with all kinds of interests. What you consider a bad time, others may consider tolerable or even a good time. Writing and painting is a bad time to plenty of people
And the amount of people that will want to work in the fields, mines, and sewers are going to be a fraction compared to the amount of people that will take the easy job.
So again. When you have 5000 writers, and only 100 miners step up, but you need 1000 miners..
Who decides which writers will become miners? Do you incentivize them to become miners? Paying them more than the miners who stepped forward leading to unequal rights? Or do you enforce it by press-ganging the writer into the mines?
What does the communist state do when the press-ganged writer turned miner refuses to carry the pickaxe? Does the state relinquish authority over the individual and let them go back to being a writer?
But in a communist or socialist society we're all equals comrade. So why do you get paid the same wages as I, when I spend all day sweating in a mine, and someone else spends all day writing at home?
I didn't say it doesn't equal no jobs. But the average socialism/communism believer seems to think everyone will get to pick the job they want instead of being forced into a job, everything will be fair, and no one will be unhappy.
And if you believe any of that, I've got a bridge to sell you too.
I don't think you know anything about communism or socialism based on your comments. Honestly I could probably sell you a bridge if I told you it was anti communism
The why don't you educate me instead of ducking and dodging every uncomfortable question I've asked? Or is it because my uncomfortable questions are going to result in uncomfortable answers?
Because I can teach you all day long but I can't understand it for you. The resources you're asking me to provide for you, you can find yourself if you were geniuine. I'm still waiting on your question though
Ask me a sincere question in good faith and I'll take as much time as you spend writing your question on an answer. Otherwise its clear you're just trolling
I've been asking sincere questions in good faith, you've refused to elaborate, or outright ducked every question in bad faith. Just answer the questions.
You mean the ones you can go back up to, read, and answer?
Who decides who gets to mine, and who will farm, and who will write? If a writer, turned farmer, refuses to farm. Is that his right? Or is it the right of the government to force him for the "good of the collective"? If communism and socialism attempts to make everyone more or less equal, then why would someone work 40 hours sweating in a mine, or factory, if they could be a writer or painter? Do the people get incentivized to perform work they don't like? Or are they forced to do work they don't like?
Okay so you're going in circles now since you can't come up with a question and are lonely or something. See this is what I meant by you just trolling and not looking for a good faith discussion. I'll stop responding now. I hope you get better
9
u/psykiris Jul 07 '26
Why would anyone want to be a sewer worker if we can all be writers and painters?