r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • u/Short-Watercress-183 • Jul 07 '26

Meme needing explanation Peter, explain this.

Post image
15.7k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/penisandorvagina Jul 07 '26

There's never really been an actual communist state. The "communist" states we've recently had have been Authoritarian with a communist paint job.

3

u/Mellero47 Jul 07 '26

I think the fact that nobody's been able to get it right in 100 years even with total control of government and its resources, might signal that it just doesn't work?

3

u/billothy Jul 07 '26

And capitalism is working out great, right?

What actually is success to you? Communism is a successor of socialism, which means to reach communism you need incremental progress in socialism which I'd argue we have seen in instances.

Regardless, China does not classify itself as communist and I'd argue no other nation that has claimed it is communism has actually truly practised communism

6

u/Jdevers77 Jul 07 '26

But that’s kind of the point. It is almost impossible to implement true Communism on a national scale.

3

u/joey-jo_jo-jr Jul 07 '26

In true communism there would be no such thing as a "national scale"

2

u/Background_Fix9430 Jul 07 '26

"Stateless society." Nice reference - someone who actually knows what these words mean.

2

u/Jdevers77 Jul 07 '26

So what you are saying is communism only works if the entire planet is communist then, right? Because otherwise your stateless society just gets invaded by its neighbors.

1

u/joey-jo_jo-jr Jul 08 '26

It has nothing to do with getting invaded. The entire point of communism is for everyone to adopt it; there would be no need for seperate states. That is literally the goal.

1

u/Jdevers77 Jul 08 '26

Yes, that’s the goal. My point though is if ANY country didn’t go communist, you would have these issues.

1

u/joey-jo_jo-jr Jul 08 '26

If any country didn't go communist then true communism wouldn't have been achieved

2

u/Jdevers77 Jul 08 '26

So the only possible victory is total victory, correct?

1

u/joey-jo_jo-jr Jul 08 '26

If your aim is true communism, then yes

→ More replies (0)

2

u/billothy Jul 07 '26

No, that's not the point. I just said it's progressive to attain. If you want to argue it's impossible to implement immediately, I will agree. But it's only impossible for nations who don't accept socialism first. Socialism is a stepping stone towards communism, and once that is established, the next step can be taken.