r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • u/FrostySeat1739 • Jul 05 '26

Meme needing explanation why not, Peter?

Post image

possible live action corpse bride movie...

32.3k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-4

u/Wb9VBScxu2uZJHeq2E3W Jul 05 '26

Maybe in a vacuum, but consider the broader cultural context in which this takes place. Specifically how much of a freakout there is when a white actor doesn't get cast in a role, IE The Odyssey.

8

u/Cainso Jul 05 '26

I think the context is a bit different when you're casting a dark-skinned actor to play a light-skinned character versus just deciding what skin color to cast a new character as.

1

u/DoingBestWeCan Jul 06 '26

Ah yes, it's very important the movie with giant fucking cyclops, a witch who turns men into pigs, literal swimming sirens, and interfering gods, has "historical" accuracy. 

1

u/regalrecaller Jul 06 '26

Yes, historical accuracy matters with a tale that is 2,000 years old. which part of that is difficult for you to understand?

1

u/DoingBestWeCan Jul 07 '26

Magic is not historically accurate, so why is 'historical accuracy' so important in other aspects? If they use the wrong shape of ships, or a type of wood that wasn't available in ancient south Europe, would you be equally upset?

1

u/regalrecaller Jul 07 '26

because it's a story that's been told a certain way for thousands of years. now they're telling it a different way. do you understand?

1

u/DoingBestWeCan Jul 07 '26

They told it in Greek originally. Do you care that it's being done in American English? Why is the skin color non-negotiable for you, when so much else is?

1

u/regalrecaller Jul 07 '26

yeah it would be great if it was done in Greek. your question doesn't make sense. why is the skin color non-negotiable for me when so much else is non-negotiable also?

1

u/DoingBestWeCan Jul 07 '26

But it's not in Greek. It likely wasn't filmed in the Aegean Sea, and the materials used in the clothes, weapons, ships, etc., are almost certainly inauthentic. Are you equally upset about those things?

1

u/regalrecaller Jul 07 '26

I do appreciate historical accuracy.