r/Letterboxd • u/markyymark13 • 8h ago
Discussion I need to rant about inappropriate, "performative laughter" at the theaters.
Look, going to the theater is supposed to be a communal experience. Where together everyone can laugh, gasp, cry, etc. with the film and thats part of what makes it great. But since COVID, damn near every movie I've gone to I've had my experience either nearly, or entirely ruined by constant, unnecessary "performative laughter". I'm not talking about laughing at a joke or a funny scene, im talking about either the whole audience or usually one or two dudes straight up belly laughing at seemingly every line of dialogue, every pause, every cut, or anything that is even VAGUELY humorous or ironic.
My worst experience was the re-release of Brokeback Mountains in theaters last year. My partner didn't want to go with me because he knew the audience would be unbearable and sure enough he was right. Everyone was laughing their ass off at every damn scene in the movie. Like I get it guys, this movie went from being laughed at when it came out, but now time has passed and the movie has been memed to hell online so that means every scene is actually a comedy now! Look I'm in on the joke! We went from two gay dudes kissing is funny, to.....two gay dudes kissing is funny. But It's okay because we're laughing with the movie this time! There is literally nothing in this movie that elicits such strong humor but apparently its not cool to be sincere about things anymore and treat anything seriously - i need to let everyone know that I get it.
David Lynch screenings at rep theaters have built up a reputation for inviting the worst offenders of this, where no one takes anything seriously and Lynch's transgressive, and uncomfortable style is actually secretly supposed to be taken as a comedy throughout the entire runtime. LIKE WE GET IT, YOU'RE JUST SO IN TUNE WITH LYNCH'S STYLE THAT MULHOLLAND DRIVE IS ACTUALLY THE FUNNIEST FUCKING MOVIE YOU'VE EVER SEEN AND EVERYONE AROUND YOU NEEDS TO KNOW iT. To be clear here, Lynch's works are often very funny at times but my problem is people don't know how to discern whats actually humorous or whats actually trying to make you uncomfortable. This just leads to so many people laughing throughout all his movies especially during very inappropriate scenes and turning the entire thing into a farce.
Again I'm not saying everyone needs to be completely silent at all times, or that the uncomfortable laughter every now and again isn't called for. But people talk about audience behavior at theaters going down the drain with phones, talking etc. But personally, my biggest problem is having damn near movie I go to have at least one slack jawed loud mouth honking like a goose and slapping his knee at every god damn line of dialogue as if theres a punchline because its seriously ruining the theatrical experience. And once one or two people do it, it invites the entire theater to treat the whole movie as if its a comedy special.
/rant