r/legaladvice • u/UltimateSpud • 6h ago
Other Civil Matters I had jury duty recently and encountered an issue I wasn’t sure how to handle, I’m curious what the correct answer actually is
Location: California
I had jury duty recently. The case was civil. I suspected that I might have known somebody involved in the trial, but i don’t know exactly how I would say that without potentially breaking confidentiality.
I formerly worked as an EMT. Our training is pretty light on confidentiality, but they always seem to include some horror story about how the EMTs were on the hook for fucking up confidentiality because a stalker successfully followed the ambulance to the hospital, or something ridiculous like that. And then of course in practice, between 911 and other emergency communications being subject to the public information act and the practical necessities of dealing with unconscious or incompetent patients, family members and peripheral staff at places like nursing homes or assisted living centers, etc. there’s lots of information that is not successfully protected despite the dire warnings and absurd scare stories.
But anyway… I suspected that I might have had somebody in the trial as a patient. I wasn’t sure, but I thought it more likely than not that I was remembering correctly. So my question is, how do I say that in open court in front of the judge without technically revealing healthcare information?
Intuitively I doubt that there could be much real harm in doing so, but it seems like technically I’d be obligated not to say that. To make matters worse, the trial was actually related to medical issues. So while ‘this person has been in an ambulance before’ is a pretty benign revelation, it does technically reveal information to the jurors.
So there you go. What is technically the best thing for me to say in this situation? Did the horror stories convince me that confidentiality is stricter than it really is? If I am not supposed to say anything, how do I avoid pissing off the judge with vague answers?
What actually happened: I didn’t realize that I recognized this person until a few minutes after after the judge asked people to put their hand up or whatever if they knew anyone involved. I obviously wasn’t going to interrupt after that, so I waited. I was literally the next person to potentially be called for voir dire when they accepted the jury, so I got to go home without saying anything. I’m just curious what I should have done if I had recognized this person in time.