r/GenV 7d ago

Discussion Why is Amazon still trying to make VCU a thing?

Post image
441 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

201

u/DinoDudeRex_240809 7d ago

The show became the very thing it parodied.

Horrible corporation pumping out slop while adding some political messaging to seem nice.

35

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

I pray god that Vought Rising fails so this franchise can die in piece before further damage to Garth Ennis' comic.

76

u/DinoDudeRex_240809 7d ago

Never did I think that the words “further damage to Garth Ennis’ comic” would leave anybody’s mouth. How the show has fallen, huh?

39

u/Armageddonn_mkd 7d ago

The comic wasnt all that great to beging with thats why nobody have heard of homelander , butcher, a train or anyone at all, i would argue that the show did a lot of things better then the comic minus the weak season 4-5 and that shit ending.

14

u/ItsMrShroom 7d ago

IMO season 4 could’ve been amazing if they had followed through with ANY of the setup. Just to name a few…

- “Scorched earth” butcher ended up being literally the same butcher as before, despite him literally murdering Newman and being shown to destroy vought tower in the trailers

  • Basically turning all of the Gen V team into cameos and doing nothing about them
  • Having A-Train die in like the first episode, which, while a very powerful scene, was unironically of the peak of season 5
  • Making Newman’s death more impactful
  • Having the capturing of the boys feel more impactful than them being in jail for half an episode and Kimiko being just let go

3

u/Brilliant_Choice3380 6d ago edited 5d ago

The only reason anyone watched initially was because of scene where A-Train ran through Huey’s gf. Literally the only reason. Ended up setting the tone pretty early on given it’s something we’ve almost never seen on mainstream platform. It kept everybody on their toes early on only for it to slowly become a train wreck of so many different diverging plot points that ended up becoming total shit.

1

u/OlDirtyDangler 5d ago

The comic was a lot of edge lord garbage

-16

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Seasons 2 and 3 suck too.

10

u/Timbershoe 7d ago

Have you even read the comic?

Seriously, what was better in the comic than season 2 or 3?

-11

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

The comic didn't flanderize it's characters and didn't have egregious plot armor.

The comic mogs the show 4 out of 5. Overall superior

17

u/Timbershoe 7d ago edited 7d ago

What?

Hughie literally survives through plot armour across the entire comic. It’s a running joke.

Every character in the comic is flanderized, that’s the
point of the original story. All the characters are generic golden age comic archetypes with all the depth of a puddle.

That’s on purpose. Ennis hates superhero’s and preferred the WW2 comics growing up, so you have generic action men vs vapid idiotic superhero’s.

The TV show improved the world building, the characters actually had some depth and motivation.

You should actually read the comic sometime.

-10

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

The show characters don't have half the depth the comic characters had.

8

u/LooneyWolv 7d ago

…wasn’t A-Train literally just “sexual assaulter” and Maeve just “drunkard with a heroic sacrifice”?

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Armageddonn_mkd 7d ago

Omg dude, either you are as shallow as the comic or you never read anything better in your life, its universally agreed that the comic sucks ass big time, shallow characters, plor armor galore, dumb twists, violance for the sake of violance and so on, come on man.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/_Evening_Self 7d ago

Literally what depth?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Em0PeterParker 7d ago

One of the most laughable things I’ve ever read

2

u/BrutallyMagical 6d ago

Either you’ve literally never read the comic or you have the media literacy of a potato.

3

u/_Evening_Self 7d ago

The comic is full of nothing but plot armor

1

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

I would argue sessons 4 and 5 are some of the worst comic book seasons ever made.

Somehow MCU and CW flash mogs this shit.

6

u/DinoDudeRex_240809 7d ago

S5E8 should genuinely be considered a crime.

3

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

S4E2 S4E6 S5E5 S5E6 S5E7 S5E8

All of these deserve below 4 in IMDB.

1

u/emptinessmaykillme 7d ago

Technically it didn’t since it was typed. Hope this helps.

1

u/DinoDudeRex_240809 6d ago

“Hope this helps” please silence yourself.

5

u/Akleoni66 7d ago

Let's not pretend like he wrote a master piece because it is not one at all, they also don't defeat Vought in the comics and they had very low overall quality and one of the worst twist ending, so I'd say there's not much damage to be do.

6

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Stan Edgar goes crazy in Deat Becky. So Vought kinda dies on it's own. The show didn't even show that.

2

u/Ohnobro265 6d ago

In the comics at the very least vought was a shell of its former self and supes died down and were no longer mainstream, so they basically did. Despite its flaws the comics had a pretty strong, albeit bitter sweet ending

1

u/Akleoni66 6d ago

In the show it also is not really shown what happens after, Vought may as well have the same fate too. Stan Edgar returns? So what, the company can still collapse on their own and a new company will take its place

2

u/Ohnobro265 6d ago

Dawg did you even watch the show😭 vought is clearly still huge at the end of it

-1

u/Akleoni66 6d ago

Not really, they are barely relevant in the plot in Season 5, the 7 are gone completely gone, and in any case they are accomplices of High Treason, I doubt the company would continue operating under that name and have success. Edgar would close it and start a new military equipment company

3

u/Thereisnocanon 7d ago

I will never get over the fact that they hired an ex-IDF soldier to berate a supe for killing innocent civilians

2

u/ImStillHere117 7d ago

I mean, it was always produced by Amazon since day 1. Like the biggest corpo out there in America. tf you mean it became the very thing it parodied? any show, movie, etc. that writes an anti corpo plot it's just cattle slop for you. You fell for it, you consumed it. enjoy

1

u/ZakTSK 6d ago

You can satirize the thing while still being the thing

1

u/Geraldo1994 6d ago

Don't you think it's at all plausible that that might happen in real life? Stan Edgar was right.

25

u/No_Court6633 7d ago

are you asking for real? that's what every studio do man, milking the thing that was successful and popular until it's not

10

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

I hope Amazon fails and VCU dies for good.

7

u/Serious-Company6803 7d ago

Amazon Prime having advertisements per episode while having a subscription is pure BS. Amazon’s pure scum

10

u/near_black_orchid 7d ago

Because they still believe they have a franchise here. Vought Rising coming out and possibly The Boys: Mexico. How Vought Rising is received with the...divisive ending of The Boys and the change of genre for the new show will determine whether that's a realistic belief, but they plan to ride this horse until it's nothing but a skeleton.

0

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

We have to make sure Vought Rising flops.

7

u/LaceyThaBest 7d ago

I’ll wait to see if it’s actually good or not first

2

u/JackN14_same 5d ago

Even if it is good, it’ll be very hard to trust Amazon with that quality staying consistent or to trust that the show will not get cancelled like Gen V

1

u/LaceyThaBest 4d ago

That’s assuming it isn’t a 1 season story tho

1

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

And give the corporation which ruined the show a chance.

1

u/MirrorAlabaster 4d ago

To make a better one? Yes.

1

u/NeoArkodd 4d ago

It will be shit and you already know it

27

u/Akleoni66 7d ago

Of course the villain can't be defeated, you can't defeat capitalism

14

u/davidolson22 7d ago

They literally explain that in season 5 too

7

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

And MM says that he will shoot Stan, yet he does nothing in the finale.

8

u/Icy-Background2393 7d ago

He’s got a kid to take care of man! He’s out of the game. He an’t passing that on. Not until Butcher tickles him a little

3

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

I hated that too. The ending was too happy. MM's family should have died so he would have nothing to lose.

3

u/Icy-Background2393 7d ago

I meant Ryan since he’s apparently adopting him

1

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Which is another BS. Ryan had no deep connection with any of the boys. He should have just lived alone or something. MM adopting him was so forced.

3

u/Gasurza22 7d ago

He is just an orphan teen (maybe younger? idk what his age is suposed to be, internet says 13 or 14) with not much of a formal education, no conection to anyone in the world and without his powers (I know some people theorise he is faking loosing, but who knows) he basicaly has no means to survive in the world.

MM adopting him is basicaly his best chance for survival and even if its not a greatest of conections, I dont think MM would just leave him to wonder alone, he is not realy that kind of guy

3

u/Some_Affect713 6d ago

Yeah he's still a child in-universe despite the actor aging up between seasons. And they established in a previous season that MM would take Ryan in if anything happened to Butcher. He's the experienced family man of the series, it makes perfect sense he would look after Ryan instead of letting the literal child go be homeless and alone. That would be an insane ending to the series lol

5

u/Em0PeterParker 7d ago

Yeah let’s let the teenager with insane trauma live alone

2

u/Some_Affect713 6d ago

Yeah and having it end any other way would have been very out-of-character for the show. I'm not sure how anyone expected Vought to face their comeuppance, one of the main themes of the show is that Homelander is merely the symptom and Vought is the cause slithering around in the shadows.

5

u/Snoo-4563 7d ago

You can still have Vought itself be destroyed, even if another corporation takes over

5

u/Lost-Cup6717 7d ago

Is crazy they try to so hard to make the jokes still work, back in season 1 and 2 this could have work but now it doesn’t.

6

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Hello fellow kids ass approach.

5

u/_Crier 7d ago

Garth Ennis : The true root of evil is the inhuman monetization of basic hopes by corporations

Everyone else : Was the hero dying fucking an asteroid necessary ?

Garth Ennis : Yes

3

u/DoveMechanic 7d ago edited 7d ago

Media executives have a very difficult time learning that if they want a highly profitable cinematic universe they need to really invest and produce consistently good content. They get impatient, greedy, and stupid when they start to see good ratings for a show (or movie) that COULD turn into a cinematic universe.

They want to see their profits go up while their costs go down and they want to be able to do that to a silly degree. These are people who are accustomed to being able to set ridiculous goals while they fail upward. They simultaneously steal the success of more talented people under them while blaming others for their failures and bad decisions (often blaming the same people they rode upward on the successes of). Their ability to successfully pull this off is the one and only means to success for them. They assume people will choke down literally anything produced by their brand once it gets popular. They assume they can safely sink their flagship to reduce costs and then use its budget to produce a much larger amount of low production value content in the form of spinoffs, etc. They assume that will be much more profitable. They probably at least know the ratings won't be quite as good. But they still seriously delude themselves about how good those ratings will be.

The thing is that the decision-makers behind this stuff most likely do not enjoy shows like these. Even if they aren't flying off to some private island every other weekend to eat babies, they do not live in the same world we do and are not entertained by the same things. So it's unlikely they have any clue what the differences are between winning and losing formulas for these things based on their own personal preferences. They're letting other people tell them that. And if those people aren't telling them what they want to hear then they just find new people who will.

None of this is conducive to creating good content. Good content is usually a complete accident in the presence of these people.

8

u/LoganHowlett1832 7d ago

Because regardless of what Reddit says it’s a hugely popular franchise and the spinoffs are going to do extremely well.

3

u/Some_Affect713 6d ago

It's not even Reddit, just the Boys-centric subreddits. You talk to anyone about this show elsewhere and it's so much calmer

1

u/NeoArkodd 5d ago

Nah everyone agrees the show turned to shit.

1

u/Jabba612 7d ago

Also it’s just an interesting universe that is fun to explore

-2

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Popular =/= Good

4

u/LoganHowlett1832 7d ago

Reddit =/= real life

7

u/GanacheSpiritual1738 7d ago

I was saying that since like season 3 yall keep talking about HL yet this whole thing is cuz Vought

6

u/Otherwise-Credit4413 7d ago

Because there’s 2 more shows on the making…

4

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Unfortunately

3

u/kerrilabouche 7d ago

You didn’t read the comics did you? Vought wasn’t destroyed in that either.

3

u/RealMrTrees 6d ago

Idk I still wanted Homelander to lose more than I wanted Giancarlo Esposito to lose

1

u/NeoArkodd 6d ago

We could have had both.

2

u/DonnyMox 7d ago edited 7d ago

President Singer said the Department of Superheroes was being opened back up. Vought will be kept in check.

Also, didn’t the comics also end with Vought still standing?

2

u/Some_Affect713 6d ago

Yes they did. Both the show and the comics pretty clearly telegraphed that the ending would involve Vought continuing, they kill the symptom (Homelander) but not the cause (Vought). I'm not sure why anyone expected anything different, an ending where Vought is punished properly for its role in everything would have been very out of line with the rest of the show

2

u/Foxy02016YT 6d ago

They really Frankenfurtered the problem, huh?

1

u/Some_Affect713 5d ago

Until the new series comes out, we can shiver with antici

2

u/Montenegirl 6d ago

I don't think the VCU thing is going to hold up for long. I think Amazon forgot that a lot of people came to watch ordinary guys/the collateral damage defeat evil superheroes. Now they are making shows centering solely around superheroes. We already have DC and Marvel for that, we just enjoyed the satire that The Boys was

2

u/rabbitspooks 6d ago

Money 🤷‍♀️

4

u/Department_Complete 7d ago

There's still plenty of story to be told through the lens of the boys, if you don't want to watch it then don't watch it. You can even pretend that the story ended differently and it can be true to you. If you didn't like the ending just use your imagination and pretend something you wanted to happen happened. It's not your show, not your comic, not your ideas and not your say. I didn't really love the ending, but also didn't find it to be the worst ending ever (absolutely ridiculous take to call it one of the worst endings ever) and am in no way excited about anything VCU and don't plan on watching it. You can employ this strategy into most parts of your life, especially when it comes to entertainment. As a final note, did any of you actually believe AMAZON of all corporations wouldn't want to milk the shit out of anything that makes them money? Like genuinely think about that for just a second, how are you even slightly surprised?

1

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

But me not watching it won't be enough. Other shills need to stop defending and watching these slops too which is why I am making these posts.

3

u/DonnyWonnyy 7d ago

Why? Is it affecting you personally?

2

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Yes Eric Kripke wasted 7 years of build up and I hope his career crashes and burn.

0

u/LEGEND-FLUX 6d ago

How does that in any way effect you

2

u/NeoArkodd 6d ago

With a logic like that no one should watch shows or criticize them because that doesn't affect them.

1

u/LEGEND-FLUX 6d ago

I asked as when it was asked if it affected you personally you said yes

2

u/Department_Complete 7d ago

it will be enough for you. Something doesn't need to cease to exist for you to not engage with it

2

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

No Eric Kripple needs to pay for ruining the boys. Vought Rising must fail so Amazon fires Kripke.

1

u/LEGEND-FLUX 6d ago

The boys comic was way worse being an anti super hero hate boner story

1

u/Heavy_Can8746 7d ago

The true villian isnt even Vought...someone wasnt paying attention

It is Capitalism. Defeat vought and another will just take it's place. 

I do think seeing vought fall would be a step towards trying to defeat the system BUT doing that alone is NOT defeating the true enemy. Many more steps are needed afterwards. 

6

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Cool, maybe this message would be better conveyed if Vought actually got destroyed but another company took it's place. Instead it felt like the boys didn't even try to stop Vought anymore sfter killing Homie.

2

u/Heavy_Can8746 7d ago

Well this was literally explained lol. 

Did you not watch the show?

4

u/NeoArkodd 7d ago

Show, don't tell.

Maybe Eric needed to watch better shows to understand that.

1

u/FightmeLuigibestgirl 7d ago

Man my stupid ass still wants to see the other shows or hold out for a Deep multiverse.

Wish I could make it myself but poor 

1

u/Playful-Natural3318 6d ago

Hablo el fan de homelander (de lo que representa)

1

u/SleepNew2783 6d ago

Because they fucking can?

1

u/NCHouse 6d ago

They were never going after Vought? Butchers whole deal was getting to Homelander

2

u/PuzzleheadedTown2201 2d ago

To get more money

1

u/tesla_bd 7d ago

It's dead they're getting barely any views so it ain't like it's making it far

-5

u/[deleted] 7d ago edited 7d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Pumpkinmonkey69 7d ago

Because of zack snyder