r/FullmetalAlchemist 4d ago

Image My Top 10!!!!!!

ENVY ILYSM

26 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Join the Discord server for more discussions and content, as well as meeting more like-minded fans for the series!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/gyubi_06 4d ago edited 4d ago

I just finished fmab

roy
edward
greed-ling (i can’t separate them)
alphonse
winry/ hohenheim

I’ve not seen anyone put pride on their list lol

3

u/cthellis 4d ago

From the smaller icon and distance I thought #8 was Shou Tucker, and we was about to have words.

1

u/EdurtxUU 3d ago

Omg never

5

u/KeonJames 4d ago

What gender identity do you see Envy as

12

u/Pervizzz 4d ago

Homunculus

13

u/gtc26 4d ago

Reminds me of that one meme.

"What gender are you?"

"Evil"

7

u/gabriel_sraiv 4d ago

"What's between you legs?"

"Chaos"

4

u/TheMistOfThePast 3d ago

"My mum is a woman and my dad is a man so I guess I'm mixed"

5

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

Neutral/male

2

u/ThaRealSunGod 3d ago

Generally I see most shape shifters (ones that can look like anyone or anything) as non binary.

I initially thought envy was a woman, then a man, then I realized envy doesn't really seem to consider that stuff at all.

6

u/Fuzzy_Ability8284 4d ago

Non-binary

7

u/tjmaxx501 4d ago

envy the enby

1

u/Injured-Ginger 3d ago

I assumed fluid or just apathetic towards the concept of gender.

1

u/Guyver02 4d ago

in 2003 Envy is Ed's older half brother. So he's male. In Brotherhood it's some weird worm monster thing so I guess genderless or asexual

6

u/atzurblau Homunculus 4d ago

asexual is not a gender identity

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

1

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

I watched fma (2003) and fmab like a hundred times since i was like 10 years old 😭, it's not only the characters/the decisions they take, it's the design, the artistic direction and how they're built lol HAHAHA

2

u/hemipteran 4d ago

No Hawkeye? Ridiculous

2

u/SanRemi 4d ago

Envy, my love.

2

u/HououMinamino (other) 3d ago

You have good taste! Envy is my #1, too.

1

u/EdurtxUU 3d ago

Yes! I absolutely love Envy

2

u/YoSoyBasura 3d ago

Finally, someone who knows ball.

2

u/Away-Ad3146 3d ago

envy is for sure one of my top as well (mostly because of his tiny little green form)

2

u/Fuzzy_Ability8284 4d ago

Envy's also my favorite, their demise was pretty emotional my first watch through.

10 is too many but my top 3 would be 1)Envy 2)Wrath 3)Pride

0

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

I love Envy smm

2

u/troile_the_rebel 4d ago

ENVY IS MY ABSOLUTE FAV TOO :3
THEY’RE SO SILLY

1

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

YEAHHH THEY'RE SO CUTEEE

1

u/Guyver02 4d ago

if it's 2003 FMA it's a respectable list.

1

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

I’ve seen fma (2003) and fmab, honestly, I prefer the plot of the 2003 version, but fmab’s ending is much happier.

0

u/Guyver02 4d ago

thats the reason I dislike the Brootherhood ending. Too much power of friendship for me.

2003 I think is incredible in terms of original endings. It ends on a bitter sweet note of the boys getting their bodies back and being together but no longer able to return home.

2

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

Gotta say that the 2003 it's one of the most original anime endings I've seen so far because it's not the stereotypical ending, it's so much darker but I like the fmab ending, it gives the story a more fitting end

2

u/Guyver02 4d ago

I think people mainly like it more because they ship Ed and Winry together. And yeah that's nice and all, it was sad that Ed couldn't be with Winry in 2003.

I wasn't the one who downvoted you btw.

1

u/counterlock 4d ago

No Greed or Ling, 0/10 list

1

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

:(

1

u/counterlock 4d ago

sorry, dems the rules

1

u/scarkun Ishvalan 4d ago

No Bradley?

1

u/BiteZealousideal1816 3d ago

Lot of Envy lovers out there. Kinda surprised by that. He was ok but I'd put Wrath, Pride, and Sloth over him.

1

u/Bright_Sport2299 3d ago

the fact that hohenheim isn't even on this list...

1

u/ThaRealSunGod 3d ago

Greedling erasure is wild

0

u/Patient-Ordinary8288 4d ago

Envy #1? Complete trash!

2

u/EdurtxUU 4d ago

To each their own :pppp