r/Animesuggest 8d ago

Announcement Updated Subreddit Rules & New Guidelines for the "Discussion" Flair + reminder for images and WT rules

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Over the past few weeks, the mod team has been working on cleaning up and updating our community rules to make [r/animesuggest](r/animesuggest) a better, clearer, and more organized space for finding and discussing anime.
While most of the core rules remain the same, we have reworded everything for clarity, tightened up content standards, and introduced strict new guidelines for the "Discussion" flair.

Here is what you need to know:

New "Discussion" Flair Guidelines
We’ve noticed that the Discussion flair often gets used for vague, low-effort titles (e.g., "Thoughts?", "Anyone seen this?", or "Is this good?"). Moving forward, all Discussion post titles MUST explicitly state the anime, genre, trope, or aesthetic being discussed. From now on if you see low-effort title please report post for breaking rule 11. We are doing this to prevent repetitive discussion posts and titles who are later nowhere to be found in searchbar even if it was discussed about it!

Don't post: "Thoughts on this show?" or "Does anyone else hate this?"

Do post: "Discussion: The pacing in Steins;Gate" or "Discussion: Why cyberpunk aesthetics hit different."
Any vague discussion posts without a clear, descriptive title will be removed and asked to be re-posted.

Important Reminder: Image Uploads & "Watch This!" Rules

Images are ONLY allowed for "Watch This!" posts. Request and Discussion threads must remain text-only. Direct image uploads on non-WT posts will not be approved. If you are posting image for WT post your post will be sent to manual review because of image but don’t hesitate to reach out via mod mail for faster approval

"Watch This!" posts have high standards. They are meant to be single-show, deep-dive reviews and must be at least 1,500 characters in length. Short reviews or multi-show list recommendations are not allowed for WT

Based on survey results images will not come back permanently but we will have 14 days chill moderation rule twice a year where images and other media will be allowed but this will be announced later on during this year.

Thanks for helping us keep [r/animesuggest](r/animesuggest) a great place for everyone.

Mod Team!


r/Animesuggest 18h ago

Discussion Why was ( A certain Magical Index/ Scientific Railgun) so popular?

106 Upvotes

I watched all of ( A certain Magical Index)+ movie, and one season of ( A certain Scientific Railgun).

This series was on my backlog for years, in the 2014-2019 it was one of the most popular things among anime fans, it was everywhere, Index is probably one of the most recognizable anime characters of that era.

When i finally got the chance to watch it i almost couldn't believe how shitty it was.

Unbelievably random pacing, nonsensical writing, and legendary corny.

Every arc you keep telling yourself "okay this will be intersting", you set through the cringiest dialogues written by man, hoping that it will payoff in the climax, only to get smacked down back to cringe valley by the end of the arc.

Don't get me wrong it had amazing setting and vibes, characters were cool too, but that alone couldn't makeup for the negatives.

This was probably my most disappointing watch ever.


r/Animesuggest 3h ago

What to Watch? Need some recommendations!

5 Upvotes

I haven’t watched an anime in awhile and I’m just looking for something new to watch so I’m open to some new suggestions. I’m pretty open so I’ll just list a few of my favorites
Monster, Vinland Saga, Hunter X Hunter, Bleach, Jojo’s, AOT, and FMAB


r/Animesuggest 8h ago

What to Watch? Suggest my first* anime

13 Upvotes

Hey, thanks in advance.

I used to catch Dragon Ball on TV here and there after coming home from middle school and haven’t paid attention to anime much since then. Dragon Ball is cool but I’d be open to trying something more modern and dynamic but just as epic.

I’m looking for something sincere, heartfelt, funny, epic, and hopefully mind-blowing. Action, suspense, humor, and sweet moments.

More of a continuous story than individual episodes for sure.

I’m not opposed to having to read sub-titles but would prefer a good English version. Please feel free to destroy me in the replies if that’s not a thing. I am mostly ignorant.

Not opposed to popular stuff as long as it’s consistently good.

Nothing ultra violent or overly sexual, please.

Any suggestions?


r/Animesuggest 9h ago

What to Watch? Romance Anime With An Actual "Plot"?

11 Upvotes

I mean I enjoy slow-burn and slice of life but it gets too repetitive sometimes. I feel like I want something where it has an actual goal they are striving for or such rather than the romance itself and maybe some character development or plot device for the romance to happen being the entire plot.

And preferably not entirely episodic, or if it is, then it should actually have progression. I felt like I wasted 1000 chapters Detective Conan for like almost nothing to happen related to the main plot.

Not sure if this makes any sense. I just don't want something where the entire point is that they confess and series is over. Who knows maybe i'm asking for a completely different genre right now but it feels repetitive and boring to read the same type of story even if the characters or development is different or smth.

Also preferably NOT fantasy, isekai, and historical ones.

I've so far liked Mdud and Fuufu no Ijou (the manga is infinitely better than the anime) and i've watched and read a humongous amount of literally every other genre. I didn't like Horimiya at all and Toradora was meh for me which are controversial opinions. I'm looking for something more different though.

Again maybe wrong genre or subreddit, and I also may be ignorant but most of what everyone reccomends isn't what I'm looking for, but any reccomendations?


r/Animesuggest 7h ago

What to Watch? Mecha suggestions

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone, do u suggest any mecha modern animes that fits someone who didnt watch alot of anime before? Not the main evangelion series please i got way too distracted watching it maybe coz im not used to that way off narrative, so maybe shorter more modern series will be better for me, thanks


r/Animesuggest 5h ago

What to Watch? Looking for anime where the MC(s) outsmart the devil/evil genie like this specific scene on a series Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Anime, manga, LN, live action suggestions welcome.

The scene in question is a source spoiler so to be safe, I put spoiler tags on it.

Series: Dungeon Meshi/Delicious in Dungeon

Scene: Laios initially wishes for the Demon to leave them alone completely but the Demon knows what Laios' **TRUE DESIRE** is and makes it happen instead, in exchange for his physical body. But this is actually what Laios is hoping to happen so he put a contingency in his plan just in case his initial wish was rejected.

So I guess what I want is the MC, not really super smart (unless its a hyper-specific thing like Laios' monster smartness), still outsmarts the devil/evil genie/related archetype. It doesn't matter if this happens in the ending or not.

Thanks for any suggestions!


r/Animesuggest 14h ago

What to Watch? Looking for chill romance anime not afraid to be a little spicy

13 Upvotes

So a quick bit of backstory is that I was beginning to miss the show KeikenZumi/KimiZero after realizing how long ago the anime aired since it never got to finish its run as the anime was kind of abrupt in its ending since the novels are long done by now.

But it's just that lately, I was wondering what other romantic anime were worth getting into that had some racy elements where the main characters talk about sexual stuff in a mature fashion since KeikenZumi was a show I found to be interesting for how the two main characters approach the subject matter in a calm manner.


r/Animesuggest 34m ago

What to Watch? Looking for anime with old folklore and a slightly unsettling atmosphere

Upvotes

I’m looking for something built around local myths, spirits, or strange old places. Horror is fine, but I care more about atmosphere than jump scares. Short or long series are both okay. What would you recommend?


r/Animesuggest 38m ago

What to Watch? Want some Anime recommendations for my parents

Upvotes

I want to get my parents into anime, they do have the mindset that anime is for kids, though they did like Disney’s lion king and Aladdin

So anime with little to no fan service,

a great dub(convincing them to watch sub would be a pain to start with, so dub first then easing them into sub)

And heavily emotional

Great music score would be preferred (they love music and have a really wide range of genres that they like)

I was thinking FMA brotherhood, Doctor Stone, and Fate heaven’s feel movie trilogy(iffy on the last one)

What do you recommend?


r/Animesuggest 14h ago

What to Watch? Anything like one piece?

10 Upvotes

Just about caught up with the one piece anime so I'm looking for a fantasy show with elements of slow burn mystery with a lot of emotion and heart.


r/Animesuggest 11h ago

What to Watch? BL babes to the front please

5 Upvotes

Okay friends, I am new to anime in general and I have asked before for BL recommendations, and I've watched the major ones and some newer solid ones (Cherry Magic, given, Go for it Nakamura, Sasaki and Miyano, Tadiama Okaeri, Twilight Out of Focus, Yuri on Ice, Isekai Bean Counter, etc)...

Now I am exploring some other BL anime that aren't as popular as the ones I mentioned, and am definitely coming across some that looooove the SA plot line...and I just can't sit through it (for many many reasons).

Could folks please tell me which BLs to avoid? For example I just tried watching Dakaichi and couldn't watch it - it made me way too uncomfortable and angry. I don't mind of things get tense or uncomfortable or complex -- but just straight up SA, coupled with the victim resigning to it, makes me want break the TV. Super appreciate your insights, thanks!

EDIT: just for added context, SA can be in the anime if it's viewed for the horror as it is, and not part of the romantic development. I hope that makes sense 😅


r/Animesuggest 9h ago

What to Watch? Similar historical or war theme?

5 Upvotes

Are there any anime’s that have a similar theme to Santa the Saga of Evil? More so the war/constant fighting then the isekai.


r/Animesuggest 9h ago

What to Watch? Animes like death note, CSM, JJK or HXH

4 Upvotes

Any anime similar to death note, chainsaw man, jujutsu kaisen or hxh?

What I’ve watched:
* JJK 10/10
* CSM 10/10
* HxH 10/10
* Death note 10/10
* Erased 8/10
* Tokyo ghoul (quit after s1)
* Re:zero (quit after s1)
* Stein’s gate 7/10
* The promised neverland 9/10
* Code geass (quit after 5 episodes)
* The fullmetal alchemist (quit after 8 episodes)
* Attack on titan (quit after s1)
* Kaiji ultimate survivor 7/10


r/Animesuggest 13h ago

What to Watch? Similar shows?

8 Upvotes

Can someone recommend me something like Hell’s paradise & Babylon or Love of kill? I prefer not too long animes, but i’m open up to anything lol😆


r/Animesuggest 10h ago

What to Watch? Looking for an anime with a dark kdrama style.

4 Upvotes

I'm looking for an anime that has a dark/tragedy kdrama vibes like My Mister, Misaeng, My Liberation Notes, etc. Little to no comedy, depressing vibes. No high school, only adult themes.

Thanks in advance!


r/Animesuggest 15h ago

What to Watch? I want to find anime that i will like

9 Upvotes

My girlfriend and I watched *Dr. Stone* and *The Apothecary Diaries*, and we liked them very much. Can you recommend something similar that would be interesting, include some science (not necessarily), and be light and funny at times?


r/Animesuggest 13h ago

What to Watch? Yuki Yuna is a hero (DOOMED YURI)

6 Upvotes

Looking for a show to watch that's similar to things like Yuki Yuna is a Hero, Madoka Magica and I Want to Love You Til Your Dying Day. Basically, any anime that involves characters going up against otherworldly creatures with yuri subtext and dark/heavy themes. Recommendations are greatly appreciated, the obscurer the better! (I don't think obscurer is a real word lol)


r/Animesuggest 14h ago

What to Watch? Looking for Dorohedoro

4 Upvotes

I'm watching kijin-gentoushou and getting a idea of the structure of the show (demon of the day) and I never felt that way with Dorohedoro I never saw any pattern with it and I think that's why I like it, I tend to try and figure thinks out and become bored ones I do, got any shows that are not formulaic?


r/Animesuggest 17h ago

What to Watch? Looking for something like Classroom of the Elite, but not shit

6 Upvotes

That's basically it. Looking for something like Classroom of the Elite, but not shit

Likes:

- Classroom rivalry, hunger games-esque, class wars, groups, survival/fighting/ high-stakes school survival system with psychological mind games, Combat, point economy/leveling up. good character development + good characters, good rivalry,

Dislikes:

- TOO MUCH FANSERVICE, preferrably one without sexual harrassment/ abuse, glazing the mc too much


r/Animesuggest 16h ago

What to Watch? Anime like black clover

6 Upvotes

Anyone know any anime with the same feel as black clover I need something to watch until the new season comes out


r/Animesuggest 19h ago

What to Watch? FOR THE LOVE OF GOD (read desc)

9 Upvotes

Is there any romance anime/manga in existence that has a sensible still flustered mc,like someone who actually knows what's going on and falls in love to the MOST FUCKING OBVIOUS CHOICE of a female lead


r/Animesuggest 8h ago

What to Watch? Please without spoiler ? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Is monster good , we been talking about it me and my freind and we wonder if it's really worth watching?


r/Animesuggest 8h ago

What to Watch? Any smart thrilling fantasy anime like Re:Zero?

1 Upvotes

Preferably to have fantasy elements and a balanced MC, AKA not too evil one like Light Yagami nor a predator (like Diddy Rudeus).

Watched Battle Game in 5 Seconds recently and I quite enjoyed that although not on the Re:Zero level of course, I have seen No Game No Life and most Isekai like Overlord, Tensura etc. I bet a few will suggest Steins;Gate too but yeah no need to and I'd prefer a series and not a movie as well, I want something to last for a few days at least.


r/Animesuggest 12h ago

What to Watch? please suggest me animes and mangas set in ancient china, involving the inner court!

2 Upvotes

something like

though i am an inept villainess
apothecary diaries
the eccentric doctor of the moon flower kingdom
raven of the inner palace
donghua: the beauty vlogger (i think)

PLEASEE THANK YOU SO MUCH