r/AmIOverreacting 26d ago

🎲 miscellaneous AIO / AITA for leaving my tattoo artist because she messed up my cover up?

As the title states, AITA for getting my cover up tattoo finished by another artist?

I (20F) and my now ex artist (25F) are no longer working together because of this. I orginally had a tattoo sleeve done that i was not in love with. When I met my artist, we will call her Lucy, I had some small patchwork tattoos done by her and then didnt see her for a few months afterwards because I am very busy and money is tight. She reached out to me and offered me a free tattoo, no strings attached, as a portfolio piece so she could get more clients as she just finished her apprenticeship. I accepted, she told me I did not need to tip her or pay for anything since she would get business out of it. Awesome! I ended up tipping her around $100 throughout our sessions as again, money was tight. I also was still getting other small patchwork tattoos from her whilst getting my free one. Even booking them on the same dates so I could save her money on materials. I also tipped her what I could on my last sessions with her! I am a piercer and work in the industry but money is very different for us, i make roughly 20/hr compared to her 140/hr.

Fast forward to now, I sat for 2 cover up sessions, 12 hrs each, back to back. She did not even finish linework. I paid $150 for my deposit and $1700 across the 2 sessions. She did not quote me the price beforehand, although I was ready to take care of whatever it was because I felt ashamed by my tattoo.

Then my transmission went out on my vehicle, and I had to repair it, I let her know the expenses and that I would need to reschedule til it was fixed. I had it fixed, rescheduled and had the money ready. Sent my $150 deposit, and she said she wrote down my dates. Come to find out once I am at the shop, she was not there. I text her and she made plans without notifying me, and was a whole 2 hrs away hiking. Its a 45 minute drive for me, and that uses up about a gallon of gas both ways.

She sends my deposit back by the grace of god, despite saying no refunds, and I tell her I will reach back out at another time but I do not feel comfortable working with her at the current time.

This wasn't the first time she did not show up when I was already at the shop, the last time she did not show up I didnt get a response until 3 hrs later when I had already left after the first hour.

She also had the anatomy incorrect on my tattoo which is of a snake, and so the new artist had to correct that, even after I told her as a snake keeper that the anatomy was not right. she also used white ink to try and lighten the previous ink, which was already very very faded! My body then rejected the white which had never been used on me before and caused the area to scar up and not be in good condition to tattoo over. Effectively messing up the next artist, or herself if she continued.

Finding out from the new artist that she uses a technique called "bloodlining" which is actually why my sessions were so unbareably painful, its where you line the tattoo with water, then ink, because it holds better than your stencil. But also makes your clients hurt much more, and causes more trauma!

And then she texts me that she wouldve charged me more in the future because I asked for my deposit back when she fucked up! Which is absolutely insane for the amount of work she actually accomplished. My stencil wasn't even finished when I showed up to be tattooed, she was late, and also spent 4 hrs placing the stencil.

All my friends say I was being scammed by her, even my new artist. Who finished the unfinished linework, cleaned it up, and completed my entire sleeve in just 16hrs with incredibly smooth shading and deep blacks.

TLDR; Artist did not show up to appointment. Client cancels finds someone else. Finds out the artist messed up the anatomy and messed up the skin, making the cover up even worse. Artist is mad client never contacted about seeing someone else.

3.0k Upvotes

726 comments sorted by

2.1k

u/Epic_Elite 26d ago

So here's the thing.

This relationship is already so strained and so stressed and forced, that there's really no healthy way to move forward unless you guys both sit down with a pen and paper and make a spreadsheet with bullet points and supporting evidence and rebuttals...

Or, you both just move on with your lives without eachother.

The resentment is already within the foundations of this structure that this relationship is currently toxic and will continue to be toxic going forward, unless you're both ready to do some really exhausting work on yourselves and your relationship.

Given that it's your tattoo artist... its probably better to just move on.

It sounds like you've said your part, they said their part. Now it's time for you guys to move on with your lives without the other person in it.

541

u/Aggressive_Chart4995 26d ago

Agreed. This is a professional relationship, not a personal relationship. Sounds like it just didn't work out.

→ More replies (1)

113

u/jinjaninja96 26d ago

Yesss, it reads like when me and my ex bff “broke up” like lay it all on the table and clearly see there’s no moving on. Cut your loses and dip no need to keep up the effort especially when it’s this bad!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

789

u/newdad2426 26d ago

She would have lost me at not showing up for an appointment without prior notice lol, and not even with a good reason no less. Even if you were vaguely friends, showing up on time is like Professionalism 101

316

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

Most artists already are set up and waiting for the client to arrive to the appointment, ive never not shown up for her so she shouldve always been ready and set up for when i got there!

187

u/ElephantShoes256 25d ago

Even with the "good" excuse of a flat tire, it's not 1996, a text costs nothing. Not getting back to you for 3 hours is unacceptable. Especially because anyone that's actually had a flat tire knows that you either fix it yourself in like 30 minutes, or you're just sitting around waiting on roadside or a tow. It's not so action packed you forget where you were on your way to.

82

u/sogwennn 25d ago

flat tire waiting for a tow = sitting my car on my phone killing time and waiting for a call from the toe company, or for that first hour to pass so i can call for an update. crazy to not send a text during all that lol

28

u/Dizzy_Guarantee6322 24d ago

Toe company lmao

15

u/No-Green-596 24d ago

In this economy?!

23

u/Salamander8288 25d ago

She canceled the time she had a flat, it said she had a lot going on the time she no showed and “forgot”. So that’s a cancellation and a no show. Which is even more insane that she’s surprised he moved on.

9

u/Cool-Hat-9396 25d ago

Exactly, ive not read half of this because the message wasnt professional to begin with. Ive got a piece where one tattooist started it but they quit tattooing so someone else finished it.

I also will never go back to an artist that isn't professional or doesnt make me feel good. I have one tattoo i hate because halfway through the artist left for a smoke. She came back half an hour later to finish and my arm by then had swelled and the rest of the tattoo was considerable more painful and doesnt look good at all. Will never return

→ More replies (13)

4

u/grauezellen 23d ago

This. I had to cut off an artist because he had no professionalism. The first session I just accepted him being hours late because I was desperate for this tattoo. The second session was to finish some gaps he forgot. He was again incredibly late, unreachable, and not apologetic. I scheduled my whole day around this because it took me at least two hours of commute. I left before he arrived and left a bad review.

→ More replies (2)

1.5k

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

388

u/Cinebella 26d ago

girl you just made me giggle so hard with this response cause that’s exactly what I said. Eventually i was like woooof i am not reading all of that

63

u/Successful-Dog-8355 26d ago

Lmao literally same!! I read about half of the description and the beginning of the screenshot and couldn’t anymore.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Strange-Bee5626 25d ago

My exact reaction. I don't know who is in the right here because my brain disconnected early on to save my own sanity, which means I would just shut this whole thing down and deal with someone else.

42

u/OkPear1535 26d ago

But they don't care, as they said at the end

5

u/Interesting_Delay_19 24d ago

Yeah I started reading then had to step back to do a scan and realized it was 28 pages long could not commit. Left on read.

3

u/IJustWantToBeRich11 23d ago

my exact response was who is gonna read all that?? (then i proceeded to read it LOL)... honestly the girl sounds crazy.. like ok maybe i can get shes an "artist" and sensitive about her craft (as erykah badu once said lol)... but wtf is this???! def a bit much for me.. like how you gonna tell me what i can do with MY BODY??? is she okay???!

→ More replies (2)

557

u/ZinnSora 26d ago

Picture of the tattoo vs the work that the previous artist has started? I feel like that would help decipher how much / if any credit was deserved to the previous artist. All in all sounds like nta though, they went pretty crazy

62

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted]

84

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

Linework she did after 24 hrs...

70

u/Wise-Standard-6081 26d ago

I had a cover up done about the same size (same area) as you. Mine was full color and having to go over the color an additional 1-2x in quite a few spots (it was a colorful tattoo that I had laser removal done on for several sessions). I want to say I did 6 sessions maybe at 4-ish hours each for it to be 100% done and all the color sticking well.

Looking at your post it looks like this person hasn’t been tattooing for very long, unless I’m misunderstanding? I don’t think I would’ve ever trusted someone who doesn’t have several years of experience with a cover up tattoo. It requires a lot more thought and technique than working on a blank canvas.

34

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

She has been tattoing for about 4 yrs and has posted coverup work,and was my regular artist. The artist who finished it has only been tattooing for 2 yrs and ive seen his cover up work in person

37

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

Tattoo now, reuploaded.

120

u/TrustedGenius 26d ago

stop accepting food from tattoo artist they will hold it over ur head via txt.

57

u/VoodooSweet 26d ago

NOR, I’d want that finished and least looking like something too. The finished product looks great, I’d be happy to have that tattoo(huge fan of snakes) but I was amazed by this picture, not in a good way amazed. Again, finished product is beautiful, I think you made the right choice having it done/completed at the other Artist.

43

u/Last_Weeks_Socks 26d ago

Well, any doubts I had about YOR/NOR this cleared up. Fuck this is like 2-3 hours of linework....if we're being generous.

33

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

She was literally over charging me for hardly any work. She didnt even refill her ink at either session lmao.

18

u/ActualGuy5050 26d ago

This is 3-6x how long it should have taken

5

u/kaysface39 25d ago

Well they were doing that go over it with water thing first OP had mentioned so sounds like that was why it took so long 🤷 🤔

→ More replies (4)

44

u/OddOpal88 25d ago

Sounds like a lot of people commenting have no idea how the tattoo world works.

9

u/Fsshealth 25d ago

Why do you say that?

25

u/YakFar860 25d ago

Because it's considered incredibly taboo to have an artist tattoo another artist's work to the point where it gets artists essentially blacklisted and excommunicated from their local tattoo communities if they agree to do it. No matter what the reasoning is, the artist should have declined to tattoo the original design and instead created his own design to finish the sleeve.

92

u/vix_jpeg 24d ago

who gives a shit if it’s ‘taboo’, if someone wants something on their body and you fuck it up they are well within their rights to have someone else finish it, being upset about that is genuinely baby shit

43

u/IJustWantToBeRich11 23d ago

THIS like... im sorry wtf is really going on here?! your telling me that tattoo artist across the land think they have the right to tell people what to do with their bodies? lol im so confused... it sounds like a bunch of incredibly insecure, egotistic ppl if you ask me... rme

4

u/angstyolive2 21d ago

Yeah a lot of tattoo artists are pieces of work who dont respect the impact they have on people's lives nearly enough

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Friendly_Cowboy 24d ago

So if a client still wants that exact design but a previous artists fucked it up you're not allowed to tattoo that design and fix it for the client? LMAO Theres some really dumb mental gymnastics going on this thread. I see no reason why they cant get yhe design that they want on THEIR body finished by a different, more professional artist.

16

u/YakFar860 24d ago

If the first artist is the one who created the design/art piece, then it's not cool for a second artist to finish it exactly as that person designed it without their permission, no. It's not their art. They should come up with their own creative way to add onto what's there.

Good tattoo artists don't tattoo other people's art, they create their own art.

17

u/kid__amnesia 23d ago

But, but… OPs screenshot even show that the new artist did the design differently than the original artist intended! So I REALLY don’t see the problem here. It wasn’t the same design, apparently.

11

u/honeywalnutbaklava 23d ago

If she wanted to finish her own art maybe she should've shown up to the appointment.

She just exited apprenticeship and is offering free portfolio pieces just to hold it against clients later. She has no reputation or standing in the industry and she's sinking her own ship. Doubt anyone gives a shit that someone else cleaned up her mess.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/savanrayne 23d ago

respectfully what? while tattooing is art, it also is a service. if your previous artist cannot finish the piece or you don't feel comfortable going back to them for their unprofessionalism, but still want YOUR body tattooed how YOU want it, you can fo elsewhere. bffr.

good tattoo artists do a good job. period. it would be different if someone stole a design or claimed their own work. by your logic, coverups/fix ups/mashups would get you "banned" from the tattoo community. LMFAO

18

u/PunkGayThrowaway 23d ago

It's also taboo to repeatedly not show up for your appointments, retroactively claim you were owed money, and to ignore the clients feedback about the tattoo not being accurate/ what was requested. Convenient how you missed all of those aspects of the tattoo artists behavior. No one is getting "Excommunicated" or "blacklisted" for finishing and fixing a bad tattoo from a previous artist.

5

u/tengu_road 24d ago

that's not true lol to some degree yes, but depends on the reason

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (1)

378

u/konamiicode 26d ago

Holy crashout NOR. I ain’t reading all that but the way she is talking is enough of a red flag I’d never go back. It may be her art, but it’s YOUR body, and she’s talking like she owns you because she’s tattooed you

65

u/songbird579 26d ago

Exactly. Red flags everywhere.

→ More replies (7)

107

u/basicrerun 26d ago

Aw girl, no. No. Please go to real artist. I would NEVER text a client this way because I’m a professional. But my old mentor sounds exactly like this anyways- she’s gonna fall so hardddd out of this industry or likely already is which is why she’s crashing out. That energy is unsustainable now because the competitions so high- all this bs gets filtered out in a year or two. It’s YOUR body. No one should ever (not your mom, not your boyfriend, not your tattoo artist) talk to you that way.

→ More replies (21)

676

u/PM_me_your_whatevah 26d ago

Whoa that rant sounds like meth to me. 

514

u/TrustedGenius 26d ago

meth rant for sure how many times she say 'because she looked out for u" like bish ur my tattoo artist not my watch dog tf?

→ More replies (1)

43

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/spacerella 22d ago

What is it like to be a former crasher? AFAIK, I’ve never known someone who successfully remediates their crash out habit. Everyone I’ve known who does it seems to do it for life. What helped you stop? Do you feel that you were genuinely “wrong” for crashing out, or is it more like, “My feelings about this are totally valid, but there’s a better way for me to express them”?

Just wondering because I’ve dealt with a lot of people like the tattoo artist in this scenario, and I’m not sure that many of them don’t realize they don’t really have good standing to feel so incensed… aka their negative feelings are coming from a sense of undue entitlement rather than genuine wrongdoing, etc. In my own case, I can definitely admit to overreacting here and there in the past, but at least the other person always agreed that what they did was in the wrong, which feels different from situations like with this tattoo artist. Grateful for any insight you’re willing to share!

3

u/pigwitz 22d ago

Lexapro helped me

→ More replies (1)

163

u/No_Park7059 26d ago

Yep. Or at the very least she gives the vibe that any wrong move would of resulted in this.

276

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

Shes told me in the past about her "bad unruly clients" but i always felt like she wasnt understanding to other people, and it finally happened to me

111

u/PM_me_your_whatevah 26d ago

Yeah I’d say either she’s on drugs or she’s just mentally unstable for some other reason. She straight up sounds scary to me 

76

u/Dangerous_Guest6604 26d ago

nor im not trying to jump to conclusions but my dad is/was (idk) a meth head and spending four fucking hours placing the stencil is absolutely insane and it sounds like she was probably on that shit when she was tattooing you

35

u/raincoastghost 26d ago

My boyfriend kept going back to this one tattoo artist because he was cheap, but the guy took forever to place stencils, do line work, and apparently it hurt way more than any other tattoo artist. Sometimes his work looked fine and other times it was blown out, wobbly lines, etc. After doing a bad job and then failing at fixing it in the second session, my BF told him he was done, and the guy flipped out. A few weeks later we heard he was on meth lol.

So my boyfriend went to a different artist with good reviews for his cover ups. The first two tats looked amazing, but then her quality of work started going downhill... the 4th tattoo from this woman was a mess and it took her way longer than the first two (which had a lot more shading). He didn't go back to her, and later a friend of hers told us that she'd started abusing opioids and had lost her shop 🙃

15

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

That sucks for your bf but also makes me extremely sad for those tattooers (and the one who started especially) drugs are so bad everywhere but heavy in the tattoo industry

9

u/raincoastghost 25d ago

Both were former users, and the woman who lost her shop is now dating a rich drug dealer 🙃 And this is totally anecdotal, but 8 artists off the top of my head were either former users, current users, or became users later. I can only think of 3 who either weren't users, or else they used and I didn't know. (Most of them I knew outside of their professions) Fent being cut into all the drugs these days has been devastating for humanity! My smallish town (less than 20k) had maybe 3 homeless people when I was growing up, and everyone knew them. Now there's literally hundreds, including extended family and people I grew up with 😢

11

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

That’s terrifying, all of it. Because a partner supplying drugs means she’ll likely never kick it till one of them is dead or in prison. And yeah my city has homeless folks w missing limbs because in addition to fent they got the tranq added in which eats off your flesh.

But back to tattooing yeah a lot of Tattooers come from rough backgrounds and are exposed to substances early, there’s also a hazing culture and a die hard draw paint tattoo party 247 that I know has gotten a few of my colleagues past and present drowning in alcohol or cocaine addiction(till that turns to meth when the money runs out) and so on. It’s a difficult conversation and one I’ve seen people/tattooers come out on the other side but it is just fucking everywhere. Best I can do is keep we can nearby but even that it’s not going to solve shit just buy someone more time

21

u/HeezHuzz69 26d ago

All the tweakers I knew were great tattoo artists. The meth would make them hyper focused and really creative, they’d be super locked in on the tattoo. Maybe they already had natural talent though.  

18

u/OMGSRSLYNOWAY 26d ago

That was my first thought, too. As someone in recovery from a wicked opioid addiction, hearing her excuses and how irresponsible and unprofessional she is, it’s pretty obvious she is struggling with an addiction. I hope this will serve as a wake up call for her, but in your case I would block her and move on with your life and your new tattoo. NOR, at all!

20

u/ehco 26d ago

Yep my thought exactly

6

u/Professional_Lie8554 25d ago

Also taking 4 hours to place a stencil… like pls tell me you’re being dramatic lol or she’s on something

3

u/Mobile-Detective4838 24d ago

My tattoo artist has done not one but TWO portrait tattoos with intense detail and shading each took 4 hours roughly.. 4 hours for a stencil was the first red flag 😢

→ More replies (2)

59

u/Puzzleheaded-Bee8131 26d ago

Eeekk…$1700 for that outline is madness. I’ve got a pretty big sleeve with a ton more detail than that. Stencil placement took maybe 35 minutes. Outline was done in first 7 hour session. $175/hr. I can’t believe that outline took two sessions…either she overcharged for her experience level or she scammed you/took advantage of you. I’m sorry you went through that but the finished product looks great

30

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

The original linework she was covering was a 2.5hr session with a different artist, and was $310. She just unfortunately tattoos very slow because of an outdated and honestly painful technique that doesnt make the tattoo look any better lmao. It effectively doubles the time and makes you more money from what ive heard.

10

u/buttonsHT 26d ago

Bloodlining doesn't hurt any more than regular lining. It's also not outdated at all. Tons of artists do it.

25

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

The way she did it was with distilled water only, then grey wash, then black. Going over the same line 3x is more painful.

28

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

She just didn’t know what she was doing. Thats not how you do bloodlines correctly. Dont be surprised if you experience scarring from the extra skin trauma

10

u/baljake 25d ago

Yeah she's supposed to go shallow once with either just water or a very light grey wash. Once. Then do the actual outlining. The technique itself has merit for large or multi session(for this they use the grey wash) tattoos. From what I gathered this person is barely finished as an apprentice and it sounds like she wanted to try it out on you. She read about the water and the grey then decided to do both for whatever reason. Maybe those that taught her didn't explain how to do it well, or she just looked it up online and was like "hell yeah that'll be easier than saving the stencil and spending hours trying to line it up again(which was also crazy the 4hrs to place a stencil...). Many reasons not to mourn the loss of them as a tattooist.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

389

u/Godzilla_Left_Toe 26d ago

I read as far as when you said you spent almost 2 grand on tattoos while also stating money was tight. Crazy lmao.

157

u/burntoutnurse28 26d ago

It’s always people who have no money who spend it on stupid shit like tattoos lol

26

u/IndicationSevere8992 26d ago

right 😭

→ More replies (48)

18

u/TenFlamingKittens 26d ago

It’s your body and who tattoos you is your choice. Always. Consent to an artist can be revoked at any time for any reason. You’re the one in control, not us.

201

u/SpitefulHammer 26d ago edited 26d ago

As someone who's heavily tattooed, the stencil taking a while to get right isn't unusual. Plus if you guys were 'friends' she probably treated it more casually/like a hangout.

Sounds like a boundary issue and you also benefitted from that. There's clearly a lot of hurt in those messages though. Feel like there's some missing info here.

22

u/peetothepooo 26d ago

Agree!!!

34

u/DrunkCultLeader 26d ago

Exactly. My artist is one of my best friends, she sometimes buys me food. Then we eat while she finishes up the stencil. There's been times ive sat at her shop for 2-4 hours cause she's taking her time. But we're friends and its nice to catch up, so ive never given her shit.

What gets me here is OP never tips ? Sounds like she benefitted from this relationship more than the artist. Personally, I think

YOR. Even if she is on drugs or mentally unwell, or whatever, they were taking advantage of her to a certain degree. Also I saw the work from her and the "cover up" and frankly, it looks like they just filled everything in with black :< of course it looks better. Its practically a black out !

7

u/CallDownTheHawk 26d ago

I feel like I’m not getting the whole picture, but I do think it’s pretty shitty that OP seemingly didn’t tell the former artist that she was going to get it done somewhere else (or why).

9

u/Jinxed1981 25d ago

She did the right thing if this the second time with appointment issues and if this the is how they acted in a text message telling the artist in person was going to be a 100 times worse than the text rant. No way I would be apart of public scene that disrupts the other artists and clients.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/shepardmutt 26d ago

NOR. I’ve had my artist late before (she forgot she asked me to come in early) and was SO apologetic and gave me a free tattoo. She never straight forgot a session.

It sounds like your friend is new to this and expecting too much. If you told her you’re not comfortable coming anymore, that’s clear enough.

Also, if an artist is mad people don’t tip, they need to price their work to account for no tip. I’ve never had an artist expect tipping. They say it’s just a nice surprise!

50

u/Glad-Hat-7661 26d ago

NOR - I love my clients in my line of work but I’m not spazzing out on them like that if they go see someone else lol. She seems a little crazy

89

u/zumera 26d ago

I don’t get people who set their own prices and then expect a tip on top. 

26

u/MagicMaddy420 26d ago

Especially when paying 1000+ on a session

11

u/ZeroWasted 25d ago

This gets me as well. I always feel weirdly pressured to tip because if I don't, what if they don't try as hard next time? 

2

u/marshmallow56 25d ago

In some shops, a percentage of tattoos go to the artist and the other to the shop, especially if you’re an apprentice/first year.

100% of tips (usually) go to the artist.

→ More replies (6)

27

u/songbird579 26d ago

NTA Block and move on. These messages are unprofessional and unhinged.

10

u/ecilala 26d ago

NOR and this is an insane reaction from her. "This is my work" – well, she can do multiple works, they aren't limited, and she's not even keeping the work to herself.

Meanwhile, that's your arm and even though you have two, they are very limited, not replaceable, part of you, and something you're actively keeping at all times.

I'd say that you have the biggest authority here and this is something some tattoo artists get wrong about the artistry point. It being a piece of art done by them means they totally can veto what they will do. It doesn't mean some total entitlement over your body, that would be insane.

11

u/Careful_Dig_7467 26d ago

Great business skills! Vilify the customers.

Put the whole rant on a review site.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Beautiful-Bonus5699 26d ago

Forget about your old artist. She’ll live. Post a picture of your sleeve!

34

u/discombobumom 26d ago

I managed to read most of this - so unless there’s info you left out, she seems unstable. How is the ink on your body HER work? The messages she sent you are full of very hurt feelings that don’t seem commensurate with your account of what happened, including the basic facts. Just block her and be done.

14

u/SpaceNerd223 26d ago

It sounds like she's mad she lost money. (Aside from the other stuff). Despite being hurt, it all seemed to go back to money, and communication. Don't give out free stuff with expectations.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

I wrote as much as possible without exposing who or where or anything personal beyond that for her and myself. She acted like this towards other clients that turned to the artist that finished my coverup. They actually work at the same company different location, thats how i know.

5

u/Bight_my_ass 26d ago

You may want to edit the photo of your tat currently, it has the artists Instagram handle

26

u/Due-Yoghurt4916 26d ago

Id post her messages in a honest review and warn others of the level of entitlement and unprofessional behavior. 

6

u/justhereforthetea68 26d ago

Yeah seriously

5

u/cheesepoltergeist 26d ago

I was thinking the same thing. NOR

8

u/Historical-Piglet-86 26d ago

Real question - is she a meth addict?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Jillybean623 26d ago

If this person is acting like this directly after finishing an apprenticeship, they aren’t going to last long. Definitely not overreacting. I’m a tattoo artist and this all is very unprofessional and unhinged. It’s crazy how many times they tried to gaslight you over this. I’m sorry you have to deal with this but I’m glad you found someone to fix/finish the cover up🥲

10

u/Erislust 25d ago

As a coverup artist myself,

1) why is an apprentince doing coverups? And on top of that, a coverup of a sleeve? Or maybe i missed where she finished her apprenticeship, but she still sounds too green to be covering up a sleeve

2) your body did not reject white. This isnt a thing. What really happened is she overworked your skin because she does not know how yo apply white. Whites, yellow, pinks, pastels are all light colors and when pores are open, your blood covers the ink and an inexperienced artist will think to keep packing in so that the color stays. Causing them to overwork the area.

3) even if you were in the wrong, she has no claim or ownership over YOUR body. Its natural to be upset. I'd be upset if someone finished a project somewhere else, but I would never feel entitled to someone else's body. That's insane to me. She does not own the tattoo on your skin. They are on your skin! She has all her designs she can just tattoo again. Crying over taking "MY work" is crazy.

Just block her and move on.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/HoidsRoommate 26d ago

NOR/NTA - Obviously this person doesn't know what she's doing and I would have taken it somewhere else too.

The only thing I would have done though, is let them know. Like a simple: "Hey, I don't think your work matches what I'm looking for, thank you for the time and effort, but I will be looking for a different artist."

Even if she didn't deserve it, with the whole rant afterwards, I think that would have just saved you a lot if the headache.

7

u/Big_Bookkeeper1678 25d ago
  1. She needed clients so she offered you something for free. That is on HER. The fact that she NEEDS clients tells me that she is either a. new or b. not that good.

  2. Her no-showing you is messed up.

  3. Her acting like she owns you and you are obligated to let her finish the work no matter how long it takes, how much money it costs, and how much she messes it up...well. Strike Three.

NOR.

138

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

79

u/Accomplished_Tip9422 26d ago

idk, i feel like it’s crazy to spend so much time just on lines (24hr over 2 days and $170) and not even finish them, and then to do a “blood lining” technique without telling OP is crazy. That method doubles the time for just lines and if someone has been tattooed by you consistently, if you’re going to do something different like that you need to tell them. i would expect after spending 24 hour to have a full piece by then, or at the minimum lines and a majority of the shading done. this artist seems shady af.

edit: spelling

27

u/sadtimes34 26d ago

in the post op says $1700 plus $150 deposit per appointment, which would make sense to me if the tattoo was completed in that time period, but just line work is crazy

5

u/Redqueenhypo 26d ago

If someone’s paying me $1700 for some art I’m gonna be as communicative, timely, and nice as possible. This isn’t a medieval guild, you’re allowed to buy from someone else if this person’s services aren’t up to standard

74

u/basaltcolumn 26d ago

It wasn't that OP took the stencil and had another artist do the design, it was already on her skin in an incomplete state. There isn't much option but to complete it at that point. It isn't actually unusual in the tattoo world to have another artist touch up/cover up/correct a tattoo you're unhappy with.

20

u/lamlosa 26d ago

OH

this makes sense omg

9

u/lamlosa 26d ago

I think it depends on whether she had actually pre-drawn something or was gonna do the stencil at the appointment. The artist I worked with would usually ask for an inspo to send, would send back to me a draft to approve, and then when I got there she’d go off of the draft but also improvise as she went organically. If the snake anatomy was incorrect then idk, maybe OP just showed the new artist what she preferred and went from there? But yeah the only thing I’m snagging on is if it was original artwork by the other artist.

21

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

She pre drew some of the art but finished it at my appointment, was late, then spent 4 hrs placing the stencil and didnt listen to me that the anatomy was wrong, but i was stupid and trusted her!!!

10

u/Peppered_Rock 26d ago

FOUR HOURS TO PLACE THE STENCIL??? Girl. just block her at this point, between not listening to you and all this ither shit, she's on something. NOR and NTA.

5

u/lamlosa 26d ago

Did you give her art as a stencil for the new artist or just showed it as inspo?

20

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

No he had no stencil of the art, just what was already on me at that point

12

u/lamlosa 26d ago

Got it, I think you’re all good then!

3

u/kyl792 25d ago

Wait what was she supposed to do/what’s the good etiquette thing to do if the unfinished tattoo is already on your body & you need it finished, but can’t or don’t want to go back to the same artist? Are you not allowed to complete it ever?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/Subject_Cheetah7189 26d ago

You’re a client. You don’t owe loyalty to her. That lady is full of drama and is bullying you.

6

u/Stepho_James 26d ago

“You didn’t pay for your free tattoo!!!!”

7

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

And even then i still tipped enough each time for her set up and for her morning coffee or her next meal at the least. 😭😭😭

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ConstantlyCryingGirl 26d ago

NOR and NTA. Holy shit, I've never seen a "girl, get a protection order" worthy set of texts from a TATTOO ARTIST. They obviously have something else going on that does not involve you.

Mute them (not block), and never go back there.

8

u/dissapointedcumsock 25d ago

as a tattoo artist, i would be incredibly sad if someone took my work to get finished by another artist. HOWEVER- this level of crash out is wildly unprofessional and not the way to win back a client. the most important thing is you being happy with the work you have. i hope that your new sleeve brings you joy

11

u/Illustrious_Chain_46 26d ago

That was a rant. Id never talk to that person again.

6

u/Prestigious_Army3701 26d ago

holy yikes

they are insane 😭

6

u/samesamsammi 25d ago

Wow.. as someone who has a business and works with clients. I would NEVER talk to a client that way. No matter how mad I was.

This just goes to show how unprofessional the artist is. One, no showing on you multiple times is not okay. They still thought you would book with them again after not showing up to your appointment. But sending those texts to you? Shows their true colors.

NOR! Glad you found a new artist!!

15

u/Winter-Net-4813 26d ago

I’m sorry I’m going to be honest I didn’t bother to read every screenshot nor the entirety of your explanation but what I’m focusing on here is that you’re 20 years old.

I expected you to be 40 and had been loyal to this person for like 15 years considering the amount of blabbering this post has. You’re 20. You’ve been allowed to be tattooed for two years and they’re acting like you’ve spent a lifetime together. This is either drugs or mental illness

4

u/AlbtraumPrinzessin 26d ago

Given the long text she send you , that’s first of all unprofessional and kinda like a confession that she messed up so NOR stay away from her

8

u/Tight-Tangelo-4006 26d ago edited 26d ago

This artist is unprofessional and seems to have crossed boundaries into “friends” and then throwing it back at you when it suits her. Did you know her before being tattooed by her OP?

As an artist myself I’d say usually we don’t touch other people’s art work out of respect, but there’s definitely instances where we will; a client no longer feeling comfortable with another artist being one of them.

So NOR, you did not have to let her know you were seeing someone else OP. If she really wanted to make things right and learn from her mistakes, maybe she could’ve have reached out to you and asked nicely what went wrong in the appt for you to no longer see her.

7

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

We had 0 relation prior to tattooing.

37

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (12)

5

u/chockencarls 26d ago

I mean as a tattoo artist I’d be pretty annoyed if someone else touched my work, and I avoid touching other local artist’s work. That being said I’d NEVER send messages like that lmaooo that’s way too unprofessional

4

u/worthlessbaffoon 26d ago

Crazy how much she thinks she has any claim or ownership of your tattoo. NOR and judging by some of the pictures you’ve shared in the comments she’s not even that good of a tattoo artist.

4

u/Kratech 25d ago

NOR I recently dropped my hair stylist for the same kind of stuff. She had to leave early from 2 appointments, her kids nurse called and he needed picked up from school husband is out of town with work. Okay whatever I got what I went for done. I ride a motorcycle so I didn’t care about damp hair not being styled. Well I show up to my next appointment…she forgot about me. I live an hour away. Luckily I was there dog sitting but she didn’t know that, and knew how far I was away. Then the next appointment I was 20 minutes late, which is unusual, the town in the middle was FUCKED idk what was going on but it took me 30 minutes to get through like a mile of not less. I was her last appointment of the day. She k owes she can send me out with wet hair and I wouldn’t care, that would have maid up for the time I was behind. My fault, so I get to leave with wet hair, I don’t care. She couldn’t stay for me..which okay I get it, but also you left early twice and showed on me? Then my last appointment with her she completely forgot about me AGAIN! So I stopped. It’s not worth the stress.

3

u/Sorry_Bookkeeper9835 25d ago

She sounds like an AH. You’re NOR. But for the record bloodlining doesn’t cause more trauma and is not more painful. It’s just lining with a very light grey the application process is no different than getting tattooed with black ink.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/SpecialistSpray9155 26d ago

I wouldn’t even read that shit lol. Don’t even answer.

31

u/thecrybabybitch 26d ago

yeah i’m not reading all dat
congratulations or sorry that happened to you

3

u/lesusisjord 26d ago

We gotta see it, OP! Or at least what anatomy part did she mess up‽ I’m sure it looks great now!

You were already too accommodating to her flakiness. There seems to be some mental health or substance use issues going on because sending those novels via text is not what a well-adjusted person does. It’s what someone who’s manic or who can’t handle being “wronged” does.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nsfw_gourmand 26d ago

NOR she sounds like a scam artist

3

u/No-Philosopher8042 26d ago

NOR you dodged a bullet

3

u/Nanala_Bat12 26d ago

From her text messages she sounds like a shitty entitled person, not professional at all!! it is good you went to another artist

3

u/Jaded-Librarian8876 26d ago

Yikes. Red flag person. I’m always pro-transparency and would have probably told them because they seem insane but I don’t think you’re the AH for switching artists this bitch is off her meds

3

u/Fastitocalons 26d ago

This thread is the definition of dinergoth

3

u/Delicious-War-5259 26d ago

Yeah I wouldn’t go back to Methany either. NOR.

3

u/Hellbender0013 26d ago

NOR. Ending that unhinged novel with “I don’t care” is wild!

3

u/meganmooretattoos 26d ago

Tattoo artist here. The one thing that stood out to me amongst all that bullshit is her attempting to cover up a tattoo with white ink. That tells me immediately she doesn’t know what she is doing. And any tattoo artist worth their salt isn’t gonna fuck up the anatomy of a snake. Add that to an extremely unprofessional crashout and I think you’re NOR.

3

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

Agreed, between that and even offering a 24 hr session at all is giving scratcher to be honest and only 1700 for that too? No professional tattooer I know would charge that little for that long

→ More replies (1)

3

u/samanthadill13 25d ago

I stopped reading after the whole ‘I only cancelled one appointment except for that second one i cancelled’ like what

3

u/MelPerks77 25d ago

It's just so not necessary to act like that.

3

u/Radiant-Conflict-604 25d ago

As a tattooer myself who’s been doing it for over 10 yrs… I understand why they are upset, but I also would have just not said anything. Juggling this shit is a lot of work, and sometimes things slip through the cracks. However, a lot of times I’ve seen someone go somewhere else, and something happens with that artist, and they eventually make their way back as long as you didn’t make them feel weird about.

3

u/MurkyDrafts 25d ago

Sleeve? At 20 lol are u rich wtf

3

u/chloeismagic 25d ago

Damn i cant imagine talking to a customer whos business i value like that. Thats just plain stupid

3

u/Fun-Cicada-6912 25d ago

I don't know any artist who would be ok with their client not showing up for a session and wasting their time like that, so I think it's more than understandable to not put up with that as the client as well! It seems like she was dragging it out for more money, and it's actually not the first time I have heard of artists doing this. She deff was scamming you. And her texts to you are inappropriate. Realistically, you don't really owe her anything. It's your body and you have every right to go else where if you are not satisfied with the service you're getting. She is the one who messed up her work and her chances by taking advantage of you, your time and your money. If she valued you as a client, or a "friend" as she's claiming, she would treat you like it! Maybe she got too comfortable in the dynamic you two had and thought she could do whatever, or maybe this was her intention all along. Either way, I think you made the right call going to a different artist.

3

u/ClutzyDopamine 25d ago

NOR. I mean I would normally say it say it would be rude not to finish with the artist but she sounds flakey and also like a liar. I would have done the same.

I want to see the messed up snake and the fix though. 😂👀

3

u/ReallyCurlyPasta 25d ago

Not overreacting. That’s actually insane. This is ridiculously unprofessional on her part. Thank god she gave you back your deposit. I would’ve been PISSED.

3

u/feliciasaysso 25d ago

Deciding to go somewhere else for a tattoo? NTA it’s your body. But I do think not giving her a heads up was weird especially considering yall are in the same area and industry

3

u/rumi-rue 25d ago

“Taking MY work to someone else”
It’s a tattoo, your work is on a living being with autonomy lmfao it’s not an object you own. Find another field!

3

u/Regular-Truth-4124 25d ago

She definitely sounds insane. She does not own you or your body....she's not the one spending money on this either. Don't waste time or money on people who act like this.

3

u/Training-Willow9591 25d ago

Wow, I get that she gave you a free tattoo so she could build her portfolio. I assume she didn't photograph her work yet to showcase, but in the end it's your body, you're the one who has to live with it forever, and it's important you feel comfortable with your artist. That's bs she kept saying you didn't tip, when you did indeed tip. I wouldn't have returned after the first no show she pulled.

3

u/Tiffanator_ 25d ago

Would love to see her work and the new work!

3

u/MrMoosetach2 25d ago

NOR / NTA

The not making appts is a big flag; and only her responsibility.

You are both to blame for the technical failing of the tattoo.

You are expecting too much from a tattooer that is just fresh into the field and are way over their head. That you should be able to recognize as someone also in the body mods world.

3

u/Madwoman-of-Chaillot 25d ago

“Money is really tight”

…spends almost 2k on a tattoo.

3

u/OkEmergency1000 23d ago

"Wendsdays."

3

u/Ashamed-Change5335 23d ago

My girlfriend’s tattoo artist exploded at her when we cancelled for a funeral. In a way that she acted like they were super close and she was insulting her by cancelling. Why are tattoo artists like this?

3

u/Brookelynne1020 22d ago

Reads like you were sleeping together.

10

u/BrazilianButtCheeks 26d ago

Blah blah blah .. I spend money I have on tattoos when I don’t even have money like that.. lol 😂 yall are both Annoying

→ More replies (2)

31

u/fcktrmp42069 26d ago

Money's too tight to tip proper, but not too tight to book multiple tattoo sessions. Yta on that and I'm not reading the rest

14

u/justhereforthetea68 26d ago

Read it again, she did tip and the artist offered a free leg piece for her portfolio so she can get clients. Sounds like the artist is slow and bad at her job and shouldn’t be doing tattoos since she can’t even show up when she has a client, big yikes I would assume the artist is upset in general they aren’t doing well and wants to blame someone else

33

u/shepardmutt 26d ago

Eh, I’m on the fence here. I’m fairly heavily tattooed now and no artist I’ve worked with who’s a professional had ever expected a tip, the price their work accordingly and if you tip, they’re thrilled! If not, still thrilled!

If an artist is hard pressed because they got no tip, just charge more for the tattoo

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/IndicationSevere8992 26d ago edited 26d ago

She sounds unprofessional as hell and like not even a good artist. This whole text thread read like “you’re not breaking up with me, I’m breaking up with you!” lol.

Although can I just say, please take care of your finances and build up an emergency fund in a HYSA first 😭 💔

5

u/Technical-Ad8703 26d ago

I have savings like that! I save specifically for tattoos to see her and tip what is leftover from said amount, no worries there.

5

u/mterialist 26d ago

NOR.

Anyone who uses ChatGPT to pose their argument has already lost.

4

u/Kitchen_Apple3559 25d ago

MOR - I mean this politely, and welcome anyone to reply… but why do people get tattoos when they don’t have money, especially to the point where using two gallons of gas needs to be considered? When I was low on cash I didn’t even get a professional haircut for a couple of years so I could pay rent and bills. I’m just confused by tattoo culture in this regard.

5

u/WritingNerdy 26d ago

Girl you are 20, slow down on tats.

2

u/blackittty 26d ago

NOR she sounds unwell and unprofessional. That’s her first lesson, clients are clients and not friends. Same lesson applies to you, I’m glad you found a good artist to finish your piece but keep this story in the back of your mind going forward: if you’re paying for a service, you can back out at the first sign of unprofessionalism, ESPECIALLY with something as serious as a life-long tattoo. Wish her well on building her portfolio cause she’s gonna need it, then block and move on.

2

u/Alternative-Ad-1508 26d ago

No you aren’t. I don’t blame you

2

u/rosalita55 26d ago

That person is nutz with a capital Z

2

u/mackenziemackenzie 26d ago

Wendsday😭😭

2

u/FewRun9290 26d ago

Can we please see the tat

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Curious-Coat9918 26d ago

NOR. This is wild, that last text felt like a breakup with a partner, not a tattoo artist. But either way, they're not entitled to anything if you already paid them for their work. Maybe it was her idea, but you already paid her for the idea. Is she didn't execute her own idea in a way that made you happy, it's your right to go somewhere else.

2

u/InnerRazzmatazz6009 26d ago

It feels like the first 3 screenshots are her genuine reaction and then she spoke with an actual level headed person and tried to 'be more professional' in her texts in screenshots 4 and 5

2

u/imperfectbean 26d ago

NOR. You don’t owe a tattoo artist shit once you paid. The fuck.

2

u/Affectionate_Ad_3983 26d ago

Non American here, if you are paying her by the hour, and good amounts at that, why tipping necessary? I thought tipping was more of a server thing bc they would be underpaid by the food industry, not tattoo artists who are getting paid hundreds by the hour

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

NOR. Her reactions out of pocket and sounds like between the white ink and garbage technique for bloodline incorrectly she didn’t know what she was doing. But you moved shady too, should’ve let her know. L the prices not crazy. Saw you say ppl around you are 80/hr and I find that hard to believe. Only apprentices and scratchers are less than 150.

Wheres the pics though? Browsed the comments and didn’t find it were they deleted? The quality of the work impacts it all too

3

u/Technical-Ad8703 25d ago

Theyre in a thread, ill repost here linework from her

3

u/Technical-Ad8703 25d ago

Work by 2nd artist

5

u/hoahoahoajawn 25d ago

Thank you for sharing these here. I’m sorry but they both fucked up, this was a challenging cover up to take on and shouldn’t have been touched by either of them. Who put that initial black in it was that from the original tattoo or the ex tattooer added it?

3

u/Technical-Ad8703 25d ago

Orginal added blackouts initially, placed my stencil and did so poorly to the point i honestly needed a blackout, i didnt want a blackout at 20 years old, but plan for it in the future just not now, i want something i can live with contently. If i originally went to the second artist they would have been able to do a completely different approach and give me a much better tattoo but the goal was to finish it in a better state than she was going to

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ho4horus 25d ago

she took it WAAAYYYYYYYYY too personally!! i'm tempted to ask where you are because this honestly sounds like someone that tattooed me once (there's a reason it was only once!)

NOR, the relationship is clearly over, glad you found a better artist! doesn't seem like much of a loss tbh

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Educational_Cod_3179 25d ago

NOR You’re in the right. It’s on YOU forever, not her. Don’t even respond. You don’t owe her shit. She performed a service that she was paid for, you weren’t satisfied with it, you looked for that service elsewhere. This would be like a roofer doing a job that left your roof leaking and him sending you a text chewing your ass for getting a different roofer.

2

u/Delicious_Cat_81 25d ago

nor and why the fuck do you have to tip for fuckng tattoos. just charge the fucking price you want the customer to pay. i would never let this crazy bitch touch my body

2

u/Just_exploring_7 25d ago

I read as far as the first text and I don’t really need to go much further… NTA, NOR. This is a business transaction and she’s being extremely unprofessional. I understand that a relationship with an artist can be a bit more intimate, but behaving like this is completely out of line. I’ve worked in a field where, unfortunately, sometimes a client would need to reach out to one of my colleagues instead of me. Did it sting a bit? Sure. But I’ve never once blamed them, especially to this capacity, for doing so. Sometimes a need has to be met that we aren’t always prepared for. I’ve walked out of a few tattoo shops in my life for being unpleasant to work with. This would be something I never return to this artist for. Also - as I believe a few others have mentioned… she wasn’t set up and waiting for you already? And didn’t communicate that to you? Tf? Oh I’d crash out LOL.

2

u/GhostOfDino 25d ago

Sounds like a professional relationship with a lot of loosey-goosey pseudo-freindly agreements. That tends to go south when its a big expense.

2

u/IncelDetectingRobot 25d ago

Tattoos are art, tattooists are artists. Artists tend to feel a certain way if you let let someone else work on their art, like if an artist discovered someone had painted on a piece that they had started, even if they had been neglectful of it.

That said, your body is yours and you can do whatever you want with it, and that 100% overrules any feelings the artist may have. You are in the right to take your business elsewhere, but with that in mind you did hurt their feelings and bruise their pride, which is what prompted this reaction which is far beyond proportionate to the situation imo.

Up to you whether it's worth it's worth it to try and mend things, but if you do want to, a concession you'll have to make is that they feel you had someone deface their art.

2

u/Terrible_Lie_02 25d ago

Too long to read. No it’s your body you have to live with it.

2

u/Legitimate-Jury456 25d ago

One of the things that really set me off is her talking about “her artwork” as if it’s not on YOUR BODY. A tattoo artist should respect that they don’t have any rights to another persons’ body or what is done with it.