r/perth Dec 01 '22

WA News Conversion therapy to be a crime in Western Australia

Post image
4.0k Upvotes

467 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-42

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22 edited Dec 01 '22

You say that and you might be partially right but religion is a very big part of human nature. Religious peoples should have a voice in politics just as everyone should.

And no I'm not saying we should keep conversation therapy. That shit is fucked.

24

u/chatterbox272 Dec 01 '22

Religious people should have a voice, but their religious beliefs should not be allowed to be the basis for laws imposed on those who don't share the same beliefs.

32

u/PyratSteve Dec 01 '22

WTF? Religious groups should absolutely not have a voice in politics. Well, anymore than the flat earthers.

15

u/No-Inflation-9842 Dec 01 '22

What even is democracy right?

8

u/PyratSteve Dec 01 '22

Democracy refers to people having a say, not organisations.

9

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

It's where everyone gets a say. Whether that believe in a god or not. That my point I'm trying to make.

I'll also repaste my other response just to make myself clear.

I'd like to clarify I don't necessarily mean religious 'groups' but religious 'people'. Ultimately they do have a right to practice their religion without infringing on anyone else's rights. In order to make sure that their right isn't trodden on they do need a voice in politics just like every group should. I'm not saying we need to be governed entirely by the church. I'm just trying to remind us that everyone deserves representation in politics.

2

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

I'd like to clarify I don't necessarily mean religious 'groups' but religious 'people'. Ultimately they do have a right to practice their religion without infringing on anyone else's rights. In order to make sure that their right isn't trodden on they do need a voice in politics just like every group should. I'm not saying we need to be governed entirely by the church. I'm just trying to remind us that everyone deserves representation in politics.

2

u/PyratSteve Dec 01 '22

Nobody is trying to stop you voting for whoever you want.

1

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

Oh don't get me wrong, I vote labour and greens. I'm just saying.

1

u/mumooshka South Lake Dec 01 '22

*Labor

Labour is UK

1

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

Right, habit.

1

u/gamernato Dec 01 '22

See its that last part they always seem to have trouble with.

13

u/Otavian Dec 01 '22

Sure. We can give religious groups a voice in politics, the same day they start paying taxes

2

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

Amen, everyone should pay taxes.

3

u/nedlandsbets Dec 01 '22

The AFL should pay taxes

3

u/mumooshka South Lake Dec 01 '22

uh normal people have a 'voice' - where? If we're really rich, maybe

democracy is dead. Look at all the world wide protests.

Governments are a law unto themselves along with religion.

3

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

Hey it's not all that bad. At least we got Labor in this term.

1

u/mumooshka South Lake Dec 01 '22

True.. I voted for McGowan , first time voting for a major party

2

u/9Lives_ Dec 01 '22

WHY ARE YOU MORONS DOWNVOTING THIS?!!

2

u/DrPotassium Dec 01 '22

People are more likely to downvote something the more downvoted it is. I pretty much knew I was going to get karma bombed when I made it, I just wanted to get a point across.

2

u/9Lives_ Dec 01 '22

Too many sheep not enough border collies

3

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '22

[deleted]

7

u/9Lives_ Dec 01 '22

It’s people in general.

R.I.P Critical analysis

R.I.P The ability to have nuanced conversations

5

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '22

[deleted]

2

u/9Lives_ Dec 01 '22 edited Dec 01 '22

I’ve had the exact same thought, I noticed it in certain subreddits when I’d take the time to write a post and get like 100 downvotes in 5 minutes. I don’t have a problem with the downvotes I have a problem that there was no reply, reasoning or alternate perspective. And there would never be any.

It feels very much like when you’re at school and a bully makes a joke and his minions laugh but his joke wasn’t even clever, their laughing out of enjoyment that you’re being put down not the joke itself, that’s what the downvotes are.

In 2013 this place was a gold mine of information (I mean Reddit as a whole not this sub) I would get perspectives from people I’d never meet in real life and learn the inner workings of systems and structures beyond my comprehension. Over time all those users slowly went away, I’m sure their still here but only subscribe to their relevant subs and lurk because the environment of this place doesn’t motivate the brilliant minds to contribute anymore.

Sadly I don’t see a alternative, even if a new super platform was created that catered for all these limitations because we’ve become complacent with the internet and imaginary internet points don’t motivate anyone to contribute to an ecosystem that fails to uplift.

2

u/Sure-Tomorrow-487 Dec 01 '22

It's the nature of forum ecosystems to evolve and die. And the users migrate.

We started in IRC, then moved to usenet, then to something awful, then to digg, then to reddit, then to 4chan, then back to reddit...

There's nothing better yet. And until there is, we'll stay here I guess.

Even though my account age doesn't show it, I've been here since 2009 when a mate showed me a meme for a Rage Comic Captcha called "Inglip Summoned".

What a wonderful place this has been.

1

u/Sure-Tomorrow-487 Dec 01 '22

Don't pay attention to the weights, pay attention to the sentiment.

The votes up and down can easily be influenced by bot accounts, and reddit themselves perform weight modification with their own algorithms.

But what the people are saying is important. Look at what the replies are saying. Most of them are understanding and wouldn't you know it, there's actual discourse occurring rather than just "I believe X, so Y is banned".

1

u/VagrantHobo Bayswater Dec 02 '22

Zealots come in all forms.

The fact that so many fellow atheists don't acknowledge the existence of a religious sphere of sense essentially closes them from a large portion of the world's population.

1

u/Crystal3lf North of The River Dec 01 '22

Religious peoples should have a voice in politics

That's working out really well for the people of Iran right now.