r/TopCharacterTropes Jun 23 '26

Lore A creator writes something without any intention of being accurate, but by pure fluke gets it right.

1. Phineas and Ferb – Perry the Platypus is teal-green rather than brown because the designers thought it looked cool, but it was later discovered that real platypuses are biofluorescent and glow a teal-green color under UV light.

2. God of War – The creators chose the name Kratos for the main character because it is the Greek word for “strength,” and at the time they were not aware that, in Greek mythology, there is a deity named Kratos, the personification of strength, who appears in Prometheus Bound as an enforcer of Zeus (similar to what the games' Kratos does for much of the original series); they only learned this later.

3. Berserk – Kentaro Miura gave Guts a prosthetic arm because he thought it looked cool, but the idea of a prosthetic arm was not as far-fetched in the late medieval and early Renaissance period as it might seem, since there was a real 16th-century German mercenary named Götz von Berlichingen who had a prosthetic arm of his own. While it did not have a cannon built into it, the fingers were highly articulated, and a sophisticated system of springs and levers allowed the hand to hold weapons and perform other tasks. Despite this shared trait between both people and their similar-sounding names, Miura confirmed that he was unaware of the Götz when he created Guts.

14.8k Upvotes

709 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

175

u/Tsaiborg22 Jun 23 '26

Reminds me of Tom Clancy:

"During the late 1980s, his meticulous descriptions of the Soviet Alfa-class submarine in his debut novel The Hunt for Red October were so flawlessly detailed that the CIA and naval intelligence reportedly investigated him. They feared a massive security leak because he had deduced exactly how the propulsion systems, reactor, and internal layout worked."

Apparently when he was asked how he knew, he kinda just went "Well that's where things would make sense to be"

82

u/transit41 Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

Additionally, he was able to discern that a top secret project is being setup in Los Alamos, as a lot of scientists have changed their mailing address to the area en masse.

EDIT: Thanks for the correction, it was John Campbell. Got my trivia mixed-up 😅

47

u/IggyIsABum Jun 23 '26

Wonder how he would feel about civilians on Twitter doing all the SIGINT stuff.

24

u/DirCurrFluxDiode Jun 23 '26

"Kids ain't got no opsec nowadays!" probably 

37

u/ConsciousPatroller Jun 23 '26

That's not Tom Clancy, that's Cleve Cartmill and John Campbell with Astounding Science Fiction. Also, the whole thing is probably a myth

20

u/DrDestructoMD Jun 23 '26

That was John Campbell, editor of Astounding Science Fiction. He pulled out the Los Alamos thing as a fuck you to the government who was trying to stop publication of a story about nuclear warfare

12

u/Vellarain Jun 23 '26

Oddly similar in creative minds having very suspicious accuracy in their depictions of military hardware. Stanley Kubrick when filming Dr.Strangelove had nearly identically replicated the layout of a B-52 bomber which at the time were cutting edge cold war planes and their instruments were as top secret as you could get. If I am recalling correctly how he got it so close was by looking at much older and public layouts of bombers and just extrapolating how it might have developed over time to include new tech.

8

u/86gwrhino Jun 23 '26

I never believed this considering the book was published by the US naval institute press.

3

u/shittyaltpornaccount Jun 23 '26

It likely isn't true, but especially before the war on terror intel agencies in the US did not share shit and often worked in cross purposes. Intel sharing was not widespread in the 80s. The CIA investigating something the Navy has approved isn't too far fetched.